Lagos: A Climate-Resilient Megacity?
Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6 Page 7 Page 8 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11 Page 12 Page 13 Page 14 Page 15 Page 16 Page 17 Page 18 Page 19 Page 20 Page 21 Page 22 Page 23 Page 24 Page 25 Page 26 Page 27 Page 28 Page 29 Page 30 Page 31 Page 32 Page 33 Page 34 Page 35 Page 36 Page 37 Page 38 Page 39 Page 40 Page 41 Page 42 Page 43 Page 44 Page 45 Page 46 Page 47 Page 48 Page 49 Page 50 Page 51 Page 52 Page 53 Page 54 Page 55 Page 56 Page 57 Page 58 Page 59 Page 60 Page 61 Page 62 Page 63 Page 64 Page 65 Page 66 Page 67 Page 68 Page 69 Page 70 Page 71 Page 72 Page 73 Page 74 Page 75 Page 76 Page 77 Page 78 Page 79 Page 80
LAGOS
A Climate-Resilient
Megacity?
2
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Aerial view of Victoria Island,
Apapa port and Lagos island
ByReinvent Media
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
3
Content
Foreword : Lagos - A Climate-Resilient Megacity?
4
A Note from the Editor
5
Kadaria Ahmed
A Flood-Free Lagos: The Regional Imperative
7
By Kerwin Datu
Effects and Challenges of Climate Change on Megacity Lagos
13
By Olanrewaju Fagbohun and Ona Osanakpo
How Vulnerability and Fragility can turn into Strength: Makoko is the
Solution
20
By Fabienne Hoelzel
Voices from the Water
26
As captured by Nicholas Ibekwe
Towards Climate Resilience in Africa’s Water Cities
29
By Kunle Adeyemi and Lisa Anderson
Climate Resilience as a Growth Opportunity for Lagos Local
Governments
35
By Kofo Adeleke
Electronic Waste in Lagos
– An Opportunity or a looming
Environmental and Health Disaster?
43
By George Richards
Disaster Management in Amuwo-Odofin
47
By Ako Amadi
Urban Planning and the Delivery of Public Goods and Services
53
By: Ayodele Arigbabu
The Green Revolution is on but is Silent - Hakeem Ogunbambi
59
Interview By Nicholas Ibekwe
Sustainable Design Strategies for Eko Atlantic City
66
By Bukky Oyedeji
The Idea That we can Conquer Nature is Foolish - Alan Owen
74
Interview By Ruona Agbroko-Meyer
4
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Foreword : Lagos - A Climate-Resilient Megacity?
It is widely expected that Lagos will become the
largest city on the African continent within the next
10 to 15 years, surpassing Cairo.
Being a melting pot of numerous Nigerian and West
African identities, cultures and religions, Lagos has been
offering millions of people dreams and hopes for a more
prosperous future. Their creativity, optimism and ability
of self-organisation have been the true heart of the City.
But due
to
its
fast
growth, Lagos
is
increasingly
struggling with urbanisation challenges like unstable
electricity supply, shortage of affordable housing and
inadequate waste management systems.
As a coastal city with many of its parts lying just above
sea
level,
Lagos
faces
the
additional
and peculiar
challenge
of
flooding.
Intelligent
and
innovative
strategies are needed to combine the requirements of
economic growth and infrastructure development with
sustainable urban governance.
For Lagos to become a ‘hot destination’ for investments
and modern lifestyles, its development strategy needs to
exploit the potential that lies in a modern, green oriented
growth based on energy efficiency, climate resilience
and sustainable development. Such an economic model
strives
towards growth opportunities for all citizens
including the poor, thus contributing to a cross cutting
increase of wealth and the reduction of social conflicts.
With this publication, the Heinrich Böll Foundation
wants to present a number of visionary approaches
spanning from flood resilient building solutions,
innovative slum transformation strategies which create
new income opportunities for the poor, to sustainable
building principles for new residents’ and business
districts.
The visions in this booklet have been shaped and
discussed by experts, communities, government
officials, bloggers and partners of the Foundation, with
whom we aim to maintain an open and public dialogue
on the development options before Megacity Lagos and
her people.
Cutting across all projects, our partners emphasise the
inclusion of Lagos citizens into urban planning and
implementation processes at the local and State
Government level. We hope that this publication
contributes insights, reflections and ideas for a broad
debate about a sustainable and equitable Lagos. So that
Lagos would be called not only the biggest but also one
of the most liveable cities in Africa.
We thank Reinvent Media Ltd who made this
comprehensive publication possible, contributing with
articles, interviews, pictures and design.
Our special thanks go to Kadaria Ahmed who edited
this work.
Christine K
Monika Umunna
Director
Programme Manager
hbs Nigeria &
hbs Lagos
West Africa Office
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
5
Nigerians as a collective are still not paying enough
attention to climate change, despite the fact that
as a result of climate change, desertification has claimed
parts of the far North, erosion plagues large areas in the
South East and flooding ravages several parts of the
South West and North Central regions.
Many Nigerians are just not making the connection. For
most, their preoccupation is how to eke out a living in a
society with widespread poverty and where there is a big
gap between the rich and the poor.
Ironically,
although
the
adverse
effects
of
climate
change can
increase poverty by damaging or even
destroying peoples’ means of livelihood, some of the
solutions that can be used to mitigate it can also provide
alternative
sources
of
wealth
creation
within
communities.
For example by turning waste to energy using bio gas
technology
in
a
community,
we
get
not
only
a
sustainable
solution
that
helps
in
protecting
the
environment,
but
also
provides
sustainable
power
supply, thereby creating a virtuous cycle of increased
productivity, economic growth and more desperately
needed
jobs.
Similar
sustainable
solutions
for
impoverished communities exist in urban farming and
high efficiency clean stoves for cooking.
As the financial and commercial heartland of Nigeria,
Lagos occupies a
special
position
in
the
country.
Virtually
all
leading
businesses
in
Nigeria
are
headquartered or have a strong presence within Lagos
and not surprisingly, it has a rapidly growing population
with projections of becoming the world’s third largest
megacity by 2015.
Megacity however, also means mega challenges. How
do you ensure the city is equipped to carter for this
rapidly growing population? How do you manage the
waste such a huge population produces? How do you
provide adequate and affordable housing at a time when
the relentless sea is reclaiming land and flooding is
making scarce land, uninhabitable for a substantial part
of the year? How do you create jobs for this vast and
growing
population
and
provide
health
care,
transportation and recreation facilities on a sustainable
basis?
The
way
Lagos
deals
with
these
questions
will
determine
if
it
remains
just
another mega city or
becomes a model mega city as it very publicly desires.
Lagos also prides itself as the city of excellence and it is
true that other Nigerian cities look to Lagos for guidance
on many matters of municipal management.
This
leadership can be extended to cover lessons on how to
deal effectively with climate change. Lagos could lead
the way and show the rest of the country that with the
right strategy, planning and will, it is possible to not only
deal comprehensively with the challenges of climate
change but also turn the minuses of climate change into
sustainable pluses.
This publication brings together ideas and real solutions
by the people who are at the frontline of addressing
climate change in Lagos, contributing to making the
Lagos model megacity move from vision to reality.
Kadaria Ahmed is an
international journalist,
media editor, social
commentator and TV
personality. Her early
career was with the British
Broadcasting Corporation
in London where she
worked as a journalist and
senior producer in the
newsroom and on the two
flagships programmes for
Africa: Focus on Africa
and Network Africa..
Kadaria was also part of a
select BBC team that
provided annual briefings
on Africa to members of
the British parliament.
Prior to joining Reinvent
Media's executive team,
Kadaria worked as the
Editor of NEXT. She can
be contacted on twitter
@stwkadaria
A Note from the Editor
Kadaria Ahmed
6
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Review of damaged
coastal protection on
Lagos Bar Beach after an
Atlantic Ocean surge,
courtesy Mbeke Efanga
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
7
In 2006 the government of Lagos state conducted its
own census, finding that 17.5 million peopled lived
within its borders, with a projected increase to 25 million
by 2015, an annual growth rate of 4%. Speaking at the
Economist conference in 2012, the governor, Babatunde
Fashola, argued further that the state must plan for a
“Lagos that can accommodate about 40 million people”1
within
a
few
decades,
certainly
consistent
with
independent analyst Population Reference Bureau’s
projections that Nigeria will grow from 174 million in
2013 to 440 million in 20502.
With so many millions emerging within
the Lagos
metropolitan area soon, the most important challenge
authorities face is how to accommodate them all in
formal developments as quickly as they emerge, lest the
bulk of them spill over into the informal sector in what
would become one of the largest failures of housing
creation the continent will have ever seen.
The Lagos state government has
responded
to
this
challenge by drawing up
“city
model plans”
for a
number
of
areas
which
together
imagine
the
transformation of almost the entire state into a sprawling
garden city metropolis. Residential subdivisions will be
organised within a super grid of highways and public
transport corridors stretching along Lagos’ coast from
the border with the Benin Republic in the west, to the
Lekki Free Trade Zone in the east. In theory at least,
these
plans
have
found
ways
to
accommodate
somewhere around 30 million residents within the state
by 2030.
This response is complicated however by the threat of
climate change. Most coastal cities are susceptible to
inundation
from
rising
sea
levels,
but
Lagos
is
particularly vulnerable. In 2008 the OECD determined
that 3.2 million Lagosians may become exposed
to
flooding from climate change as a result of rising sea
levels, increased storm intensity and land subsidence,
making it the 15th most vulnerable in terms of exposed
population of all 136 of the world’s million-person port
cities3. This is consistent with a figure of 3 million
produced
by
the
earliest
detailed
impact
studies
available on Lagos made in the early 1990s4, and the
range of between 2.3 and 4 million produced by the
latest available review commissioned by
the United
Nations Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO)
in
20125.
Thus
the
challenge
is
really
how
to
accommodate
these
future
millions
as
quickly
as
possible in formal developments and on dry land, both
of which are in undersupply in Lagos state.
As
the Portuguese etymology of
the name
implies,
Lagos state is characterised by a chain of lagoons and
The challenge is really how to
accommodate these future
millions as quickly as possible
in formal developments and on
dry land, both of which are in
undersupply in Lagos state.
A Flood-Free Lagos: The Regional Imperative
By Kerwin Datu
Kerwin Datu is the editor-
in-chief of The Global
Urbanist - an online
magazine analysing
urban development issues
worldwide. Originally
trained in architecture, a
field in which he worked
in Sydney, Paris and
London over nine years,
he holds an MSc in
Urbanisation and
Development from the
London School of
Economics and Political
Science (LSE), the
programme that inspired
the magazine, and a PhD
in Economic Geography,
again from LSE, focused
on the role of global and
regional city networks in
economic development.
He continues to write on
international cooperation
on urban issues.
Ibadan Expressway
Flood aerial photo
by Lagos State
Ministry of
Environment
8
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
tidal creeks, each encircled by wide belts of swamps and
lowlands. The
tributaries
that feed
into
them carve
muddy gullies through the shallow slopes that rise to the
north. Each year, a few more feet of foredune along the
Lekki peninsula wash away into the sea, exacerbated by
colonial-era groynes that prevent replacement sediment
from being deposited by longshore drift.
Beach sands need long, smooth, linear coastlines to
allow waves to replace as much sand as they dislodge as
they roll from west to east along the Bight of Benin;
perpendicular projections
such as
the
groynes and
western sea wall of Eko Atlantic interrupt the process of
sand deposition for several kilometres to their east each
time, causing erosion in Lekki to continue unabated.
With nowhere else to expand into, it is exactly these
swamps and lowlands that Lagos intends to fill with new
urban development. The total projected population for
the coastal areas of Badagry (to the west), Apapa (to the
south) and Lekki (to the east) under their respective city
model plans is around 11 million people by 2032, of
which the above studies make clear that about one-third
will be placed directly in harm’s way.
Lessons from Italy
How can Lagos countenance placing so many millions
of its future residents on vulnerable land? According to
the city model plans, the key will be the clearing and
upgrading of the city’s existing storm water channels,
and
their expansion
into an extensive hierarchy of
swales, drains, canals and basins to channel surface
runoff throughout the new development areas before
draining naturally into the lagoons.
The people of the Lagos
metropolitan area can no longer
countenance a future where
they are forced to squeeze along
increasing fragile low-lying
coastal areas. Only by adopting
a regional approach to planning
will an entirely climate-resilient
Lagos megacity become a
realistic possibility
Lagos coastal
creeks and Islands
from the air by
Reinvent Media
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
9
Well,
this
may address
the
increasing volumes of
rainwater brought by the more intensive storms expected
across
the state, but
it
does not address
the other,
monstrous impacts climate change is expected to bring
to Lagos: rising sea levels, tidal surges, water logging of
soils, subsidence and erosion, salination of the water
table, and the health problems and diseases that will
spread in the resulting saturated environment.
There are really only two ways to prevent rising waters
from flooding and infiltrating the land occupied by these
millions of future Lagosians. The first is to establish a
much more technologically advanced array of barriers
ringing any low-lying areas marked for development: a
high sea wall along the Badagry and Lekki coastlines;
barriers across the mouth of the Lagos Lagoon and at
key thresholds along its western and eastern reaches; an
assortment
of
dikes
and
berms
running
overland
between
these points, and relief channels
to reduce
pressure outside this encirclement. If the Lagos state
government really wants to house 11 million people in
these
low-lying areas,
then we are
talking
about
something akin to the MOSE (or “Moses”) Project under
construction across
the Venetian Lagoon
in Italy, a
lagoon of similar scale to the Lagos Lagoon system, and
which has already cost the Italian government $7 billion.
This would be on top of the several billion dollars’ worth
of drainage works the Lagos state government already
hopes to carry out under its current city model plans.
The alternative would be to choose not to locate the great
majority of these 11 million or more Lagosians in these
low-lying areas, though this cannot be achieved simply
by outlawing development in certain parts. Sufficient
land must be found elsewhere. Fortunately, this is one
resource
that
the
Lagos
metropolitan
area
has
in
abundance if it looks to the north.
Look North
Rather than attempt to squeeze so many of its growing
millions onto its narrow, water-logged coastline, the
Lagos
metropolitan
area
could
grow
much
more
comfortably and securely by shifting the bulk of that
growth into the outlying suburbs of Ota, Ifo, Agoro,
Ijoko and Alagbado to the north and Ibafo, Loburo and
Ogijo to the northeast, and developing other suburban
centres beyond
them.
It
could go even
further by
adopting
a
truly
regional
approach
to
planning,
LAGOS
21 million:
Current population, making it Africa’s
most populous city
356, 861:
Total area in hectares making it
Nigeria’s smallest state
10,000:
Resident commercial ventures
2,000:
Industrial complexes
22:
Industrial estate
FAST FACTS:
Victoria Island
Traffic jam by
Aderemi Adegbite
10
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
establishing a constellation of major satellite cities by
expanding the existing towns of Abeokuta, Sagamu and
Ijebu Ode into important poles of economic growth and
residential opportunity within the region.
This would create a polycentric metropolis similar to
Delhi
in
India
with
its
satellites
Gurgaon, Noida,
Faridabad and Ghaziabad, or São Paulo with its Santos,
Campinas and São Jose dos Campos in Brazil. Turning
the north of the Lagos metropolitan region into attractive
centres of growth for businesses and residents alike so
that they absorb the lion’s share of the region’s future
millions would arguably be a better use of its funds than
fighting a losing battle against climate change in the
flood-prone
west,
south
and
east.
The
Lagos
metropolitan area already draws much of its food and
water supply from these northern areas, and will have to
continue to invest in developing these resources in these
areas,
come what may. To
invest
in
their
urban
development would be a natural extension of
these
realities.
The problem is that all of this wonderful higher ground
is
not actually
in Lagos state;
it
is
in
its
northern
neighbour, Ogun state. Yet
this artificial distinction
should not prevent the people of the Lagos metropolitan
area from considering this obvious and rather promising
opportunity. This metropolitan area has spilled over into
several
local
government
areas
of
Ogun
state—
particularly Ado-Odo/Ota, Ifo and Shagamu—for many
years and will continue to do so. It will be increasingly
a matter of happenstance whether a new member of this
metropolis finds their home in this state or the other. It
thus behoves this metropolis to think about this territory
holistically, especially since this opens up a whole world
of solutions to the problem of climate change. And one
of
the
most effective may be, as has often been
whispered by authorities, demanded by residents of
border suburbs, and recommended by administrative
reformers, to merge these two states into one coherent
entity.
There are two versions of this idea. One is to merge
Lagos and Ogun into a new single state. While this
version meets with a lot of knee-jerk resistance, it is
worth restating its merits. If the border between these
two
states
evaporated
tomorrow,
and
a
single
administration found itself in command of the whole
area, many of the constraints facing the planning of the
metropolitan area would
themselves disappear. This
enlarged state’s planners would have immediate powers
to encourage development to the north of the Lagos
metropolitan area,
to relieve pressure on
the fragile
coastal areas. They would have immediate powers to
Attempting to plan and manage
the two states as separate
territories is becoming more and
more impossible and
counterproductive, creating a
sense of rivalry and competition
where coordination and
community is required.
Aerial view of
Ogun River
Flood near
Ikorodu
courtesy Lagos
State Ministry
of Environment
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
11
effectively plan and manage
the exploitation of
the
entire territory’s water and energy resources, without
artificial competition from a competing administration.
They would have immediate powers to plan a single
integrated
metropolitan
transport
system. And
they
would do so with a single state bureaucracy, at perhaps
half the cost of the two state bureaucracies that now
operate across this territory.
Readers from outside the country may not be aware that
the
redrafting
of
state
boundaries
is
a
common
occurrence in Nigeria; since independence in 1960 the
country has come together five times to do just this,
evolving from a republic of four regions in 1963 to a
federation of 12, 19, 21, 30 and then 36 states (plus the
Federal Capital Territory of Abuja) by 1996. Usually,
existing
states
were
further
subdivided
to
bring
government closer to neglected areas within those states,
but areas were also occasionally reassigned from one
state to another. The concept of redefining state entities
for
developmental
purposes
is
a
well-established
institution within Nigerian governance, and we are
arguably overdue for another round.
In fact, had Lagos state not been split off from the
Western region as a precursor federal capital territory in
1967, it would never have been separated from Ogun
State when the Western state (as it was then renamed)
was split into Ogun, Ondo and Oyo States in 1976. The
panel led by Ayo Irikefe (later Chief Justice of Nigeria),
which recommended the breakup of Western state in the
first place, had recommended that the young Lagos state
be reintegrated with the new Ogun state at the same
time. This was rejected by
the government on
the
argument that the recently autonomous population of
Lagos would become a minority within this proposed
Ogun state, and that the Lagos metropolitan area needed
closer attention than Ogun state would bother to give it.
Well, that is obviously no longer a legitimate argument.
The Lagos metropolitan area is now a major force, with
the fortunes and communities of Ogun state increasingly
intertwined with it. Attempting to plan and manage the
two states as separate territories is becoming more and
more
impossible, and counterproductive, creating a
sense of rivalry and competition where coordination and
community is required. It creates artificial constraints
and forces Lagos state in particular to make terrible
decisions as to where its future tens of millions of
residents should be forced to live.
Internationally, a single state comprising
the Lagos
metropolitan area and its family of satellite cities would
be most directly comparable with the state of São Paulo.
Home to 42 million people and with 19 million people
in
its
core metropolitan area,
the
largest
in
South
America,
São
Paulo
is
very
much
the
economic
powerhouse on that continent that Lagos wishes to be
within Africa.
Negotiating administration
If Lagos and Ogun States are unwilling to consider this
great opportunity, then they must be willing to consider
the second version of this idea, which is to cooperate in
the creation of some other powerful administrative
entity that can coordinate action and enforce decisions
between them. The previous attempt at this, the Lagos
Megacity Development Authority put forward in 2007,
fizzled out for many reasons, chief amongst which was
bickering over the budgetary contribution to be made by
each of the three parties involved, (Lagos, Ogun and the
Federal governments).
To look abroad again, the salient comparison here is the
National Capital Region (NCR) of India, home to 45
million people and with the 22 million people of the
Delhi metropolitan area, the largest in South Asia, at its
core. The NCR comprises the National Capital Territory
along with portions of neighbouring Haryana, Rajasthan
85%:
of Lagos’ population that resides in just 37% of
the state’s territorial land mass
78%:
of Lagos’ entire land mass is occupied by low-
lying land and wetlands
Over 80%:
of international air traffic in Nigeria is accounted
for by Lagos
Over 50%:
of Nigeria’s energy consumption which Lagos
accounts for
**SOURCE: Lagos State Ministry of the
Environment, Office of Drainage Services.
http://www.moelagos.org/pool/5cc/RESILIENT
%20DRAINAGE%20INFRASTRUCTURE%20
MODELS%20%20Panacea%20For%20Sustaina
ble%20Development%20Of%20LASG.pdf
FAST FACTS:
12
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
and Uttar Pradesh States, the four of them agreeing to
delegate regional planning powers to an NCR Planning
Board (NCRPB). This institution offers nearly 30 years’
experience
in
negotiating
budgetary
arrangements
between the four state-level governments and with the
Indian central government, which the three governments
of the Lagos metropolitan area could learn from. These
lessons include the possibility of allowing any future
Lagos Megacity Development Authority to raise its own
revenue by levying taxes and issuing bonds and loans,
just as Lagos State does now.
Whichever means
are
explored,
a
climate-resilient
Lagos metropolitan area will not come about by packing
several million new residents along a fragile coastline,
and spending billions of dollars to hold back the sea. The
cheapest and most effective solutions will only come
into view by adopting a regional planning approach in
which all levels of authority responsible for the Lagos
metropolitan
area
come
together
to
find
ways
to
accommodate these new millions in safe areas as fast as
possible, before they have no alternative but to settle
themselves in harm’s way.
End Notes:
*For images of the MOSE Project in Italy, as crucially cited by author: http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:MOSE_Project
1 http://www.dailytimes.com.ng/article/fashola-plans-40-million-residents
2
http://www.prb.org/pdf13/2013-population-data-sheet_eng.pdf
3
Nicholls, R. J. et al. (2008) “Ranking port cities with high exposure and vulnerability to climate extremes”, DOI: 10.1787/011766488208
4
French, Awosika and Ibe (1995) “Sea-level rise and Nigeria: potential impacts and consequences”, http://www.jstor.org/stable/25735710
5
Gilau, Dayo and Najjar (2012)
“Climate change scenario and coastal risk analysis study of Lagos State, Nigeria”,
http://www.moelagos.org/pool/Asmerom_LagosCoastalVulnerabilityStudyApril92012.pdf
Ocean surge
control efforts at
Alpha beach
Lagos .courtesy
Tunde
Akingbade
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
13
Lagos State, with a geographical size of 3,577
square kilometres1 is one of 36 states together with
the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja that make up the
Federal Republic of Nigeria.
Located
in
south-west
Nigeria,
Lagos borders
the
Atlantic Ocean coastline
in
the south. The State
is
characterized
by
a
high
and
rapidly
increasing
population2; flat topography; a heavy concentration of
GDP-generating
industry and
infrastructure near
the
coast;
high
dependence
on
rain-fed
agriculture;
dominant vegetation of tropical swamp forest, which is
facing rapid decline over land-use, and extensive coastal
areas.
In a recent study on the socio-economic impact and
public perceptions of flooding in Lagos, it was noted
that:
…
urban
flooding has
led
to
the damage of
personal and public properties ranging
from
house utensils, foods, books to cars, building and
schools. About 39% of the respondents have their
economic activities affected by
flood and
the
monetary value of loss in business due to flooding
from single storm event range from $84.75 to
N8474.58.3
Due
to
flooding on January 10, 2011, 25 corpses
(including those of 11 children) were recovered from
two canals at Dopemu and Aboru
in
Agege and
Alimosho Local Government Areas.{Endnote}
The State, in appreciation of the reality that communities
are
vulnerable
to
impacts associated with extreme
weather events, and are already experiencing slow-onset
climate change, developed the Climate Change Policy
2012-2014
document.
This
is
commendable, as
the
policy’s goal is to guide government decisions about
adaptation planning, development, and a transition to a
more climate-resilient future.
But how well do policy-makers and development actors
within
the
State
understand
the
interrelationships
between the impacts of climate change and such issues
as
energy,
waste,
food
security
and
disaster
management?
Maybe the fact that we are
local communities outside the
sight of the international
community is why nobody is
bothered about us
Effects and Challenges of Climate Change on Megacity Lagos
By Olanrewaju Fagbohun and Ona Osanakpo
Professor Olanrewaju
Fagbohun, Ph.D., is a
Professor of
Environmental Law, and
also holds the Chair of
Chike Idigbe
Distinguished Professor
of Law at the Nigerian
Institute of Advanced
Legal Studies. He is a
director on the Board of
the Environmental Law
Research Institute
(ELRI). He can be
contacted via
<fagbohun@elri-ng.org>
Ona Osanakpo, LLM
(Aberdeen) is a Research
Fellow with the Nigerian
Institute of Advanced
Legal Studies, Akoka,
Lagos. She can be
contacted via
< osanakpo@gmail.com >
Flooded street in Upper
Makoko Lagos, courtesy of
Rosemary Yadua
14
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Components of the Lagos State Climate Change
Policy
The Lagos State Climate Change Policy (LAS-CCP)
was developed to assist the State with a more strategic
and cooperative approach to: responding to the impacts
of climate change; maximizing any potential benefits of
the changing climate as well as benefiting from existing
and future instruments including the Clean Development
Mechanism, Nationally Appropriate Mitigation Action,
Reduced Emissions
from
Deforestation
and
Forest
Degradation.
The document is structured to
“complement existing
state
and national development and sectoral plans,
policies and strategies,”4 and the various Multilateral
Environment
Agreements
(MEAs),
regional
and
international
conventions,
treaties
and protocols on
environment and natural resources to which Nigeria is a
party.
The LAS-CCP identifies its primary priority areas as
climate
change
adaptation
and
disaster
risk
management, with mitigation as its second priority. The
policy is to be reviewed every three years to take into
account emerging issues, challenges and trends.
Case Studies
Participatory research was carried out in 15 case-study
communities in Lagos State5. Interview sessions were
conducted with 82 community leaders, who have spent
a minimum of 40 years in their respective communities,
with at least 5 community leaders chosen from each
community.
Efforts were made to ensure interviewees had some
understanding
of
climatic
issues
and
how
these
influence livelihood security and choices. This was to
get deeper insights into the topic and its dynamics, using
an evaluation of past and current situations in these
communities, and learn from them the kind of future
they
desire.
The
semi-structured
interview
guide
included questions related
to weather events, flood,
energy, waste, food security and disaster response and
management.
The 15 case-studies and research areas covered the five
administrative divisions of Lagos State: Badagry, Epe,
Ikeja, Ikorodu and Lagos Island. The communities were
chosen from each division to achieve balance: Ajara
Agbovipe, Ajido and Iba communities from Badagry
Division; Akesan, Mosan-Ipaja, and Anifowoshe from
Ikeja Division; Lakowe in Ibeju-Lekki, Epe Central, and
Odogbawojo from Epe Division; Ibeshe, Ikorodu central
and Ijede from Ikorodu Division; and Badore Eti-Osa,
Obalende and Langbasa from Lagos Island Division.
The research areas were typical of rural, suburban and
urban
communities.
They
had
different
types
of
ecosystems and diversified livelihoods; mixed levels of
poverty and educational attainment; lack of access to
energy; food insecurity; sensitivity to climatic factors,
and stressors like economic crisis and land pressure.
The case studies presented evidence which shows a
complex range of interactions, and reveal that a wide gap
still exists between adaptation investments and policies
on the one hand and effective intervention strategy on
the other.
Case Study Findings
This
section
summarizes
findings
from
the
15
communities covered by the field research.
a)
Energy Issues
All the respondents reported poor electricity supply for
their respective communities. 87 per cent said that on
occasions when
they had problems with electricity
transformers, they have had to contribute money at the
level
of
community
development
associations
to
purchase transformers. While respondents in almost all
other communities noted that the government has not
been
responsive
to
their
complaints
regarding
this
problem6, respondents in Akesan and in Badore Eti-Osa
said that the state government (in the case of Akesan)
and the Local Council Development Area (in the case
of Badore Eti-Osa) supported
their communities
in
providing transformers.
..They are waiting for our
people to get sick as a result of
poor waste management before
they integrate us into their
systems.”
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
15
Olusosun Waste
Dump site courtesy
Reinvent Media
All
the respondents were unanimous
that poor and
unstable electricity supply has been a major setback in
the growth and development of their communities. This
has significantly increased the cost of living, resulted in
wastage of
food
that ordinarily would
have been
preserved if there was power and destroyed several
small and medium size businesses which are heavily
dependent on electricity but have owners that could not
afford alternative energy sources.
A common strategy adopted to cope with incessant poor
electricity supply is the use of generators. Regrettably,
in addition to high generator maintenance costs, some of
the respondents confirmed the negative repercussions of
using generators in their communities include carbon
monoxide
(CO)
poisoning
from
the
toxic
engine
exhaust,
electric
shock
or
electrocutions,
and
fire
incidents.
Over half of respondents (62%) are aware of the Lagos
State Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources and the
Lagos State Electricity Board, but say that the State’s
interest at the moment would appear to be on public
institutions. In this respect, some public institutions are
being moved out of the national grid and connected to
the power supply generated by the state government’s
infrastructure.
The respondents see
this as a
good development but have no
clear
understanding
of
how
government is planning to help
households and SMEs
to also
have
uninterrupted
power
supply. Only about 24 per cent
understood that the effect of the
Lagos State independent power
plants
is
that
it
would ensure
24-hour
uninterrupted
power
supply to public institutions, and
concomitantly
increase
power
available from the national grid
to service households and SMEs,
since
whatever
the
public
institutions are leaving off will
become available.
b)
Waste Management
In Akesan, Mosan Ipaja, Anifowoshe, Ibeshe, Ikorodu
Central, Ijede, Badore Eti-Osa, Lakowe, Epe Central,
Langbasa and
Iba communities municipal waste
is
managed
by
the
Lagos
State
Waste
Management
Authority
(LAWMA)
under
the
Private
Sector
Participation
(PSP)
arrangement.
While
66%
respondents who participated in the study say that the
arrangement has been quite effective, respondents in
Lakowe, Epe Central, Langbasa, Akesan and Mosan-
Ipaja added that because of the irregularity in collection
of waste by the PSP officials, a number of people resort
to dumping their waste indiscriminately in drains, by the
roadside or in the Lagoon. As one community leader in
Epe Central noted:
“The
spasmodic
and
irregular
manner
of
collection of waste by LAWMA and its agents is
such that many households resort to dumping
“The fact that waste from our
communities are not picked
regularly is a fundamental
missing link in the efforts of the
state to see to our well being.”
16
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
their waste by the side of the road, in canals or
rivers or attempt to burn them inside metal bins.
When LAWMA people eventually come, they tell
us stories that their vehicles broke down.”
Another respondent in Lamgbasa said:
“The fact that waste from our communities are not
picked regularly is a fundamental missing link in
the efforts of the state to see to our well being.”
Majority of respondents agreed that
the
rate
paid
for
collection
is
reasonable.
Communities like Odogbawojo and Ajido are yet to
benefit
from
the
PSP
arrangements;
consequently,
residents manage
their
waste either by burning or
throwing them in drains and other water bodies. They
expressed a desire to be properly integrated into the PSP
arrangement. One of
the
Community Development
Association leaders said:
“Waste collection needs to be elevated as one of the
essential
services.
I
know
that
they
collect
regularly in the cities. Maybe the fact that we are
local
communities
outside
the
sight
of
the
international
community’s
is
why
nobody
is
bothered about us and our complaints of poor
management of waste. Maybe they are waiting for
our people to get sick as a result of poor waste
management before they integrate us into their
systems.”
c)
Food Security
Climate change has consequences for agriculture and
resource
management.
All
the
respondents
were
consistent in remembering that 10 to 15 years ago, the
climate in their area was marked by rainfall between
April
to
late
August/early
September;
from
late
August/early September to November, they have what
they called the “second rainy season” which is not as
heavy as the April/August rains. Then follows a cold
spell (harmattan)
in
late November/early December,
which may extend to early January; thereafter, January
to March, is dry. According to the respondents, over the
past 10-15 years weather patterns have changed. What
they
have noticed
includes
increased
frequency of
prolonged dry spells with attendant higher temperatures,
later onset and earlier cessation of rains,
increased
frequency of heavy storms and
increasingly heavy
rainfall, causing floods.
Given the high level of dependence of most of these
communities on agriculture, fishing, petty trading and
artisan works,
the
risks
associated with
the erratic
rainfall,
flash
floods, high
temperature and shifting
seasons
have
included:
shortage
of
freshwater
for
drinking and fishing; higher levels of infections and
diseases; crop failure, reduced yields and harvest losses,
as a result of inability to predict and plan critical stages
in
the farming season (food
insecurity); rising food
prices, resulting in reduced accessibility of food; loss of
livestock;
destruction
of
homes
and
government
infrastructure and displacement of families. Commercial
farming and fishing is practically dead in most of the
rural communities, while petty-traders and artisans have
found themselves idle and grossly discouraged.
Some of the respondents noted that there was initial
support for smallholder agriculture, including access to
farm inputs such as fertilizer and pesticides but all these
schemes appear to have collapsed. They further noted
that life has become difficult due to how flooding has
negatively affected small scale
livestock production,
which is what people sell in times of crises to buy food.
To cope with food insecurity, almost all the respondents
noted that members of their communities have resorted
to a mix of different strategies, ranging from seeking
help
from
extended
family
members,
attending
uninvited parties at weekends to salvage leftover food,
reducing food consumption and begging for alms. Other
strategies include driving commercial bikes, (okada);
sale of personal assets, sale of farmlands, modification
of crop production through planting of earlier maturing
varieties and increased application of fertilizers, which
have invariably, destroys farmland.
Majority of respondents expressed a need for more
government support to alleviate food insecurity. They
are currently not aware of any strategy in this regard.
Many wondered why
the government knowing
that
many families live below poverty line, is not thinking of
social safety programmes that can assist with subsidized
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
17
food rations. All respondents were unanimous that if any
such programme is being planned, every effort should be
made to ensure it is administered transparently so that
poor families who are the intended beneficiaries are not
excluded. All respondents agreed that rapid population
growth of Lagos has serious implications for planning,
and poses further challenges for food security.
d)
Disaster Management
Several of the communities have faced climate related
disasters, particularly storms and floods at different
times.
Ajara Agbovipe experienced both storms and flooding
in 2010. When a storm hit Ajido in 2012, there was no
government
response or assistance and community
members had to resort to self-help. They replaced their
personal properties
that were destroyed and erected
wooden
bridges
on
roads
that
had
collapsed.
Respondents in Obalende said they were the victims of
a
storm
sometime between 2009 and 2010 which
destroyed
the
roofs
of
several
houses.
Although
government officials came to inspect the damage, they
rendered no assistance. When respondents were asked
what role
the Lagos State Emergency Management
Agency
(LASEMA) played,
they
said
the
Agency
played no role during the crisis.
The
situation
is
different
in
some
of
the
other
communities. Respondents in Akesan say that when in
2005 and 2006
they had devastating storms
that
destroyed houses and infrastructure in the community,
the state government responded with relief materials
such as food, stoves, lanterns and dresses. According to
one of the Community leaders from Akesan:
“…
when
the
incident happened,
it
was quite
overwhelming and we were quite helpless. Then,
we called our representative at
the
House of
Representatives Chief Olaitan, who in turn called
on the Governor at that time, Asiwaju Bola Tinubu.
Both of
them came down
to see
the extent of
devastation. The assurances of support that the
Governor gave us when he was
leaving
was
fulfilled within 24 hours.”
All
respondents
from Akesan noted
that
while
the
intervention did not deliver all the community’s needs at
the time, it gave some succour.
Anifowoshe experienced severe floods most recently in
2011 and this affected the bore-hole which is their water
source.
Their
representative
at
the
House
of
Representatives
provided
relief
materials
for
the
community and since then the government has also
constructed drainage to protect against future floods.
Flooded Street in
Okun Alfa Lagos, by
Tunde Akingbade
18
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
They complained about a company, NIGERITE, which
has
channelled
its
drainage
system
towards
the
community, with the result that the Community Primary
School is still regularly flooded.
Iba experienced floods in 2003 and 2004 due to a lack of
drains. Respondents from the community were satisfied
that
roads and drains have since been constructed.
Consequently, they no longer get flooded. In the case of
the storm that ravaged Odogbawojo, respondents noted
that the government assisted the community with funds
but the money was given over two month after the
flooding
and
its
distribution
was
not
efficiently
coordinated. A number of people who did not get
government funds and were unable to afford repairs of
their damaged buildings relocated from the community.
All the respondents stated that they are not aware of any
strategy that has been put in place by government to
guide communities on how to prepare or respond to
disasters or the impact of disasters. In terms of potential
risks, respondents in Lakowe, Odogbawojo, Obalende
and Langbasa mentioned flood risks due to a lack of
drainage and construction of buildings on wetlands.
Those in Epe Central also mentioned flooding caused by
blocked drains, fire outbreaks due to hoarding of fuel
and destruction caused by falling trees during storms as
a result of a lack of understanding on why some trees fall
during storms and others do not. For respondents in
Badore Eti-Osa, the worry is about flooding caused by
the sand-filling of the sea.
Conclusion
The impact of Climate change is increasingly calling
into question the ability of the government to improve
the resilience of people, particularly those in vulnerable
communities who are already experiencing
impacts
associated with extreme weather events and slow-onset
climate change.
This research, a case study of 15 communities in Lagos
State, reveals that the impacts of climate change are
significantly threatening food security and challenging
the survival of inhabitants. It is eroding the resilience of
the people
to
current and
future climatic stressors,
trapping them further in poverty.
Issues such as energy, waste management, food security
and
disaster
management
interact
considerably
in
increasing resilience. In comparison with other states in
Nigeria, it can be said that Lagos State has been quite
dynamic in putting forward laudable initiatives that can
help shape adaptation investments. Reference can be
made to the power projects,7 which are designed to run
on natural gas as a primary fuel source. Natural gas and
renewable energy have been identified as key elements
of a transition to a cleaner and more secure energy
future. Lagos is also active in the area of integrated
waste management
–
for instance, there are plans to
establish a gas utilization system to collect methane gas
from some of its dump sites. Regrettably, a number of
the initiatives are yet to be felt by the people. While the
ineffectiveness of some of
these
initiatives
can be
excused on the basis that they are in the development
phase, a few of them that are already on stream such as
support for farmers, and mainstreaming of adaptation
strategies for local communities, suffer from poor and
inconsistent implementation.
There
is,
therefore,
the need for much more robust
implementation and monitoring,and a more nuanced
understanding of how people adjust to and thrive in the
face of climatic and other related stressors.
What
the
case
studies
reveal
is
that
beyond
the
imperatives of global best practices, effective policy
coupled with practical and innovative strategies will
have
to be grounded
in a synthesis of community-
specific reflections. It is only then that Lagos State will
be better guided in the implementation of its policy
processes, while vulnerable communities will be able to
benefit from and make informed resilience-enhancing
decisions.
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
19
End Notes:
●
A
copy
of
the
Lagos
State
Climate
Change
Policy
2012-2014
can
be
accessed
here:
http://developmentdiaries.com/wp-
content/uploads/2013/03/Lagos-State-Climate-Change-Policy-First-Draft_27.03.2012.pdf
●
A
copy
of
the
Lagos
State
Climate
Change
Adaptation
Strategy
(LAS-CCAS)
can
be
accessed
here:
http://nigeriaclimatechange.org/docs/lasAug2012.pdf
1 Lagos State has an area of 356,861 hectares out of which 75,755 hectares are wetlands.
2 The 2006 National Census figures put the population of Lagos State at 9,113,605 out of a national estimate of 140,000,000 plus. This has been
strongly disputed. Parallel count by the State during the census put the population at 17.5 million. The UN estimates that at its present growth rate,
Lagos State will be the third largest megacity in the world by year 2015 offer Tokyo in Japan and Bombay in India.
3 S. Odunuga and others, ‘Socio-Economic Indicators and Public Perception on Urban Flooding in Lagos, Nigeria’, (2012) Special Publication of the
Nigerian Association of Hydrological Sciences <http://www.unaab.edu.ng> accessed 26 January, 2014.
4
These include sectoral policies and strategies in environment, water, land, forestry, coastal and marine systems, energy, transport, health,
agriculture, fisheries, disaster risk management, and gender among others.
5
This was conducted by Environmental Law Research Institute (ELRI), a non-profit Organization for the protection of the environment and
promotion of the human health.
6
Respondents in Odogbawojo, Lakowe, Ajido, Obalende and Langbasa noted that they informed both the State and Local governments, but, there
has been no response. In the case of Iba, promises have been made by the local government, but, no timeline was given to fulfil same.
7
Island Power Project Expansion; Alausa Power Project; and Ikeja GRA Power Project.
Flooded Street in
Ikoyi Lagos by
Reinvent Media
20
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Vibrant and colourful Lagos, the big economic
hub of West Africa and possibly even beyond
has high ambitions. It aims to become "Africa's Model
Megacity", attract extensive international investments,
offer modern lifestyles, and even join the BRICs.1
It is already a large metropolitan area and its target of
becoming a more developed region will bring more
challenging side effects: More people will need more
energy due
to
the
upgraded
living
standards;
the
demand for mobility will increase and stretch existing
infrastructure to its limit, and the waste production per
capita will grow dramatically. Ecological damage may
affect the growth potential of the region as settlers
increasingly
factor
in
an
ecological
sustainable
environment in deciding which locations are desirable.
In Europe and in the United States rivers and other
ecologically
sensitive
environments
are
being
retrofitted
and
the
creation
and
maintenance
of
attractive and intact recreational spaces has become a
key area of focus in urban planning—especially for
those
cities
that
aim
to
attract
highly
qualified
manpower.
Lagos is located at sea level, and that itself presents
some challenges. Globally it is expected that general
sea level will by rise by over one mm a year until 2100.
This global phenomenon may locally be reinforced by
the fact that developed and wealthy regions usually
have more sealed surface, which will increase the storm
water runoff. This is likely to be the case with Lagos
Pragmatically and inventively,
the people of Makoko have
found ways to deal with
permanent flooded grounds—
a reality that may increasingly
become the norm in many
other peoples' lives.
How Vulnerability and Fragility can turn into Strength: Makoko is the Solution
By Fabienne Hoelzel
Fabienne Hoelzel
(dipl arch ETH MAS
gta) has recently
founded FABULOUS
URBAN, her own
urban design and
planning practice,
focusing on large-
scale projects in
emerging and
developing regions
Makoko Community,
courtesy of
Fabulous Urban
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
21
which has
started
to
work on
controversial
land
reclamation projects, both in the lagoon and at the
seashore. All these activities may additionally raise the
local
water
level
and
lead
to
extended
seasonal
flooding. These issues of common concerns are being
discussed
amongst
scholars,
professionals,
and
politicians inside and outside of Lagos, with diverse
conclusions although one thing seems to be accepted by
all, that all Lagosians are likely to become victims of
the consequences of rising water levels and the poor
are
especially
vulnerable.
One
of
the
important
questions is therefore how one can prevent floods. The
answer is most probably that there is no way to prevent
floods. When confronted with water, a powerful nature
force, one has basically only one choice: Learn to live
with the water; learn to live with the flood; learn to live
with the given climate condition
This leads to the question of how to achieve a more
attractive, livable city that is economically competitive,
and where its settlements are not damaged regularly by
flooding. This is particularly pertinent for Lagos which
has to deal with the existence of the large informal
space production and its result—slums2, shantytowns,
low-income areas. Roughly two-third of the Nigerian
and Lagosian population
lives
in
slums,
informal
settlements or low-income areas. Whilst the spread in
percentage is slowly dropping, its absolute number is
growing.3
Lagos
has
so
far
not
developed
a
comprehensive slum-upgrading approach. Successful
models in this respect have been implemented in Brazil
and some of its largest cities over the last years and
decades. Cities like São Paulo and Rio de Janeiro are
comparable to Lagos in terms of population size and
dynamic growth and may serve as role models for
Lagos—not only because slums are being upgraded but
mainly because the slum dwellers become the official
owners of their houses and have tenancy for the land.
However,
slums
have
an
incredible
innovation
capability and perhaps some of the answers sought can
be found in slums. Due to their extreme poverty, slum
dwellers develop a series of efficient measurements.
Often,
they
use
shared
facilities
for
cooking
or
sanitation, against a small fee. Slum dwellers do not
need coaching
in how
to decrease
their ecological
footprint- the cause for many global and local problems
humankind is currently facing—it is already low. The
less people have and therefore consume the less waste
they
produce
and
the
less
general
environmental
pollution they create. Slum dwellers live extremely
densely and occupy little space. They usually do not
Makoko is not a problem; it
offers a solution
Makoko waste
recycling
visualization, by
Fabulous Urban
22
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
have a car and use their own feet for transportation or
affordable, informal community transportation.
An example for such an informal settlement in Lagos is
Makoko.
Large parts of the Makoko settlement are in the lagoon,
well visible from the Third Mainland Bridge, one of
Lagos' major traffic arteries. The Makoko people build
their
wooden houses on
stilts.
There are different
academic controversies and interpretations whether this
tradition
is an ancient one, going back
to
the 19th
century, or whether it is rather a new phenomenon, only
a few decades old. However, considering the natural
condition of the Lagos region, characterized by two
lagoon
arms,
several
larger
and
smaller
streams,
connecting to the hinterland, swamps and mangrove
vegetation—this form to settle in the shallow lagoon, the
stilt architecture seems to come naturally. The people
settling in the lagoon, no matter what the driving force
behind it seem to have found a particularly unaggressive
way of living in coexistence with the water.
The other side of the coin, the lack of sanitation, which
afflicts women in particular; the lack of land tenure
security; the extreme poverty; the fact that many people
have high debts incurred in order to be able to run their
micro-businesses, which are often not profitable, and the
related insufficient income situation (roughly half of the
Makoko people lives below the official poverty line, on
less
than 1.25 US$ per day), results
in
the endless
recycling of poverty The
fact that people have no
income or an sufficient income, and the lack of reliable,
stable income sources, is therefore by far the greatest
problem that needs to be addressed.
On the problem of flooding though, the people of
Makoko may be living on the answer. Flooding damages
infrastructure and architecture if it is inappropriately
constructed and is not flexible enough. In Makoko
residents have
learned
to
live
with
the
ambiguous
character
of
the
water.
They
have
developed
an
alternative
lifestyle
in
terms
of
construction,
transportation, and
local businesses. Many Makoko
people are in fishery and related businesses, and the only
means of transportation and trade is the boat. While the
style of construction appears to answer the question of
living in harmony with the waters it is true that the
houses in Makoko are not always secure but this is more
to do with the poverty of the people and therefore an
inability to construct with the right materials.
The pioneering, alternative, yet precarious Makoko way
of living was the departing point of a project proposal.
As part of the working group of the Makoko/ Iwaya
Waterfront Regeneration Plan, elaborated and submitted
to Lagos State Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban
Development in 2013, the proposal looked at how
vulnerability and fragility can be turned into strength,.
Combining the existing local knowledge and wisdom
with a new resource-based local economy for and by the
locals, based on the specific spatial and social conditions
can provide answers to the challenges ahead. Climate
change—this is the current assumption—will lead to
increased flooding and even new permanently flooded
grounds. This describes exactly the Makoko condition.
Therefore, Makoko is not a problem; it offers a solution.
The "Makoko system" possesses a great capability to
adapt to climate change and its expected consequences,
the increased presence of water in our life. Pragmatically
and inventively, the people of Makoko have found ways
to deal with permanent flooded grounds—a reality that
may
increasingly become
the norm
in many other
peoples' life. The strength and specificity of the Makoko
way
lies
in
the
robust,
almost
autarkic
way
of
construction and lifestyle that should be reinforced and
upgraded with an appropriate and therefore adaptable
infrastructure system—which is flexible, low-cost and
independent enough to function throughout the year.
Hence, it can teach us something, even on a global level.
It has the potential to become a worldwide showcase.
This can be achieved if the many lacks – for instance
reliable,
stable
income
sources,
any
kind
of
infrastructure
whatsoever
(waste
management,
sanitation, energy etc.)
–
can be turned into micro-
entrepreneurial opportunities while still relying on the
local intelligence in how to deal with the water. Any
The bio-gas technology is low-
tech, robust, simple to
implement and easy to
maintain, producing renewable
energy with a waste-to-value
philosophy and in closed loops
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
23
kind of wired or centralized system would hardly follow
the logic of the existing settlement structure and would
especially not meet the criteria of a flood and water
resilient
system.
The
implementation
of
small,
decentralized biogas plants on water, which use the
locally accruing organic waste as feedstock, operated
and owned by the locals create a resource-based and
therefore sustainable local economy. The biogas plants,
run by sun light that is abundant in Lagos' tropical and
hot
climate,
are
designed
as
multi-purpose
public
infrastructure,
also
providing
biogas
cooking,
homegrown food (dunged with the fertilizer from the
biogas production), simple water harvesting and water
filter systems, toilets and showers, and a doctor's room.
The so-called neighbourhood Hotspots offer a wide
range of community services and are at the same time
the "brains" of the new organic waste economy. The
biogas
technology
is
low-tech,
robust,
simple
to
implement and easy to maintain, producing renewable
energy with a waste-to-value philosophy and in closed
loops. The organic waste,
the
feedstock,
is
locally
available, and will consist of human waste, fish guts, and
organic
garbage
from
the
households,
plants
and
vegetables. The "Neighbourhood Hotspots" are shared
facilities, a place to learn, a place to gather, encouraging
personal
initiative,
personal
responsibility,
and
entrepreneurial activities.
The
suggested
flexible
infrastructure
through
the
network of Neighbourhood Hotspots creates a resource-
based economy, creating different job profiles, which
are all coordinated by
the biogas cooperative. The
income of the Neighbourhood Hotspots (or the biogas
cooperative) will be sufficient to pay each worker an
appropriate salary and still save money in a fund for the
general maintenance of the facility in order for it to be
self-sustainable.
The
Neighbourhood
Hotspots
are
supposed to be completed by two recycling centres on
water, which deal with solid waste, mainly plastic, in
cooperation with local waste management stakeholders.
All the job opportunities that come with the new organic
waste economy are described and visualized in so-called
Opportunity Cards. All the suggested measurements are
summarized
in
the so-called Makoko Urban Design
Toolbox, which also contains construction advices, how
precarious
houses on
the
water
can
be
stabilized,
upgraded and additionally equipped with simple water
harvesting systems and sanitary facilities.
Again zooming out to the Lagos metropolitan scale,
Makoko—upgraded
with
the
suggested
flexible
infrastructure
and
resource-based
economy—could
offer opportunities for everybody. The neighbourhood
could fully sustain itself, with a waste-to-value system
that uses one of the biggest problems of our days, waste,
as a source for income through energy production and
Biogas system
visualization by
Fabulous Urban
24
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
recycling. The combination of the existing lifestyle and
the new infrastructure will not only enable the Makoko
people to upgrade their neighbourhood themselves but
will also contribute a possible solution in the local and
global search for answers how to adapt to rising sea
levels and more flooded grounds.
Big,
unidirectional,
and mono-functional
structures,
relying on centralized infrastructures and undiversified
economies
are
extremely
vulnerable.
An upgraded
Makoko may demonstrate ways on how how Lagos can
decentralize its supply system and how it can come to
grips with the tremendous and growing waste water and
garbage
problem;
namely
by
empowering
the
neighbourhoods and local communities. Diversified and
small-scale structures are sustainable and more resilient,
especially in times of crises.
Last
but
not
least,
the
combination
of
the
stilt
architecture
and
the
flexible
infrastructure
with
renewable energy
sources
opens
the
doors
for
an
additional income source: soft and green tourism, both
for
the
local
population and
international
business
travellers. Makoko has not only the potential to explore
the possibilities of how to live with the water. It can also
become a new public and green recreational area with
wetlands in the heart of Lagos, showing visitors the
genius loci of the metropolis. Fish restaurants, markets,
manicure and beauty shops, simple bed-and-breakfast
offers, combined with boat tours, may complete the
offer.
Makoko
could
be
connected
through
water
transportation with other
locations on Lagos Island,
Victoria Island, and other fishing villages in the lagoon
towards
Badagry.
An
upgraded
Makoko
would
contribute
to
the
diverse
and
colourful
Lagos
experience,
in
which
the
Makoko
people
could
economically
and
socially
participate,
without
being
evicted
but
with
the
confidence
that
they
can
contribute to a
prosperous
and
sustainable
Lagos megacity. Slum-upgrading is not only a social and
human act but the economic inclusion of millions of
people. People who work and earn an income, consume
goods and service, pay taxes, and are able to engage in
civil society. Makoko could be the starting point for a
more inclusive, green, sustainable, and enjoyable Lagos.
End Notes
1
Lagos State Investor Handbook. A guide to business and investment in Lagos State, 2012
2
UN-HABITAT defines a slum household as a group of individuals living under the same roof in an urban area who lack one or more of the
following:
i.
Durable housing of a permanent nature that protects against extreme climate conditions.
ii.
Sufficient living space which means not more than three people sharing the same room.
iii.
Easy access to safe water in sufficient amounts at an affordable price.
iv.
Access to adequate sanitation in the form of a private or public toilet shared by a reasonable number of
people.
v.
Security of tenure that prevents forced evictions
3 Index mundi, United Nations Statistics Division (retrieved data from data base in December 2013)
Makoko water
harvesting
visualization by
Fabulous Urban
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
25
Makoko has the potential to become a worldwide showcase for a flood resilient, ecologically and socially sustainable neighbourhood,
based on the wisdom of an ancient local architectural tradition. The Makoko people have cultivated over decades a simple,
beautiful, yet visionary way of construction and way of life how mankind can deal with permanently flooded grounds—a serious
and real threat in the future of millions of people .
Consequently, we suggest promoting Makoko as a leisure and tourism destination within a Lagos-wide tourism strategy, including
vibrant Victoria Island, the future Lekki Free Trade Zone, the North-West axis of the Lekki lagoon to Badagry, and the activation of
the fantastic urban and water assets of the Southwestern coastline of the Northern arm of the lagoon with Makoko as its heart.
Makoko is the ideal location to experience how people have learned to live on, with and from the water instead of fighting it.
We suggest not only creating new entrepreneurial opportunities such as urban manufacturing, leisure and tourism, but also the
improvement and re framing of existing opportunities such as market and trade , fishery and fish processing.
Last but not least, we suggest a contemporary community-based approachas it is applied by many pioneering countries such as
Brazil, and as it is recommended by UN Habitat and similar organizations.
Makoko Regeneration Plan
We suggest combining the local
tradition
of
building houses on
stilts
with
low-cost,
low-tech,
flexible
and
therefore
highly
adaptive
infrastructure–a topic, which is very much in the focal
point of many governments and countries. We further
suggest
linking
it
with
micro-management,
micro-
entrepreneurial
activities, renewable energies and
closed-loop production cycles.
Credits:
FABULOUS URBAN, Geneva
Fabienne Hoelzel, founder, director
Dácil Rodrigues, Mélanie Jeannet, Saskia Niklas
with David Monney, London
Partners: Serac, Heinrich Böll Stiftung, urban spaces innovation
$$$$$
$$$$$
$$$$$
$$
$
$
$$$$$
$$
$$$$$
$$$
construction costs
ma intenance costs
URBAN
FABULOUS
le isure and tourism
Flexible infrastructure and
shared facilities
income/person
18 000 N minimum income1
target area
+
-
amount
of jobs
FABULOUS
URBAN
Improved and new bus iness
opportunities
26
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
My name is Maria Agbani. I’m 25 years old. I’ve
been married for 5 years and I’ve 2 children. I
sell smoked fish. I buy fish from the cold room at Ijora
and I sell them at the Agric Area. As you can see, I’ve
not been trading for some time now because the price of
fish has gone up and I don’t have the money to buy fish.
I need like N12, 000.00 ($70) to buy fish from the cold
room. I don’t do any form of esusu ( a local group based
saving scheme) because I don’t have the money to make
my own contribution. People are generally broke in the
community. If you approach anyone for loan, instead of
giving you the money you need they will start narrating
their own financial problems to you. I don’t have money
but I’m not in debt.
I was born here and I’ve lived here all my life. Even if I
have the opportunity to live somewhere else, I would not
go. What will I be doing there? All I want is money to
trade.
We have a good hospital here but it’s private. Recently,
my son almost died because
I
couldn’t
afford
the
hospital bill. We need a public hospital here. My kids are
at home because I don’t have the money to send them to
school. I don’t know how much the school fee is in the
community school. They were attending a missionary
school
but
the
school
was
shut
down
after
the
missionaries
left
and
teachers weren’t getting
paid.
Besides,
the
community school is no
longer
accepting
new
pupils
because
it
is
already
overcrowded.
May be when the newly
built school opens I will
enrol them there.
My
husband
is
a
fisherman. He’s gone to
fish now. We’ve been
live by the little money
he gets from his daily
catch.
I use most of the waste
I generate, such as plastic bags and cartons to smoke
fish. I don’t litter the water with them. I also participate
in
the monthly environmental sanitation. We move
about in boats and pick up any waste in the water, which
are put in a large boat that takes them for disposal.
We take part in the common Christian festivities such as
Christmas, Easter and New Year.
My aspiration for now is to raise enough money to
restart my trade and hopefully I would save enough
money to send my children to school.
Voices from the Water
My kids are at home because I
don’t have the money to send
them to school’.
As captured by Nicholas Ibekwe
Fish Sellers in
Makoko, by
Fabulous Urban
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
27
My name is Sarah Yorunfun. I’m 40 years old. I’m
a mother of five and I’ve been married for 20
years. My first daughter got married last year. I started
this business as a young girl with
my mother and I’ve been hawking
on my own for 15 years now. The
net worth of the goods in my boat is
about N35 000.00, ($206). I sell
bread, ice cold chocolate drink and
a local lemonade made from herbs
and a spice known as “adoyo” .
I’m comfortable living in Makoko
and I don’t want to go anywhere
else. This is where I was born and
I’ve been hawking with my boat
since
I
was
young.
I
have
no
intention of quitting this way of life.
We don’t
have
access
to
loan.
Personally I make enough money
from this business but when I need
more money I borrow from friends.
I make at least N4, 000.00 ($24)
profit
every
week
from
my
business. The money is not enough
but I manage it well.
There is a hospital here. I gave birth
to all my children here. My dream for the future is to
make my business larger than it is now. I may be selling
something different from what I’m selling now but I
don’t want to stop hawking with my boat. This is what I
love to do.
I want the government to allow us to remain in this
community. This is where I grew up and I’m raising my
children here. I want the government to also provide
social amenities here because there is no government
presence here. There are no public hospitals here, for
instance, and the private hospitals are too expensive.
We don’t litter the water. All we do is to take our bath
here. Most of the wastes you see around here are from
the nearby canal. During the rainy season the canal is
opened and waste flows into the community. We are
not the responsible for the contamination of the
environment. We excrete in the water but the excreta
don’t stay here. They are carried by the waves deep
into the lagoon.
Sarah
Yorunfun,
Canoe food
hawker , by
Nicholas
Ibekwe
I don’t want to stop hawking
with my boat. This is what I
love to do
28
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
The conceptualisation of
Makoko as a floating city
complete with a floating
school prototype by the
Architecture and Design firm:
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
29
Africa, the most vulnerable continent to
experience the devastating consequences of
climate change, has undergone rapid urban
development during the last decades. 1 While several
nodal cities, such as Lagos, Nigeria, have experienced
rapid urban growth, the quality of life for most of its
challenged informal settlements have not seen
significant improvements. Due to the impact of
climate change; rising sea levels, increased rainfall and
flooding are becoming day-to-day reality, while
modern infrastructure seems unavailable when it
comes to informal settlements, such as Makoko, in
Lagos. Makoko is a fishing community that rapidly
developed on water rather than land. The local
residents have adapted their lifestyle, to build and live
on water, forming an aquatic city - a civilization on
water - with almost no paved roads, no land and no
modern infrastructure It is a nevertheless a highly
organized community with rich social and cultural
systems. The essence of Makoko offers challenges yet
solutions to the problems of overprized land, housing
shortage and flooding. At the same time, it requires
improvements and developments2. NLÉ has
committed to enrich this collective and spontaneous
effort with expertise in the field of innovative and
adaptable architectural and urban solutions. The pilot
project of ‘Makoko Floating School’ was launched in
2010 and has stimulated the local community and
Lagos state to engage in a long-term participatory
design process for a school project and new ways of
building and living on water. However, NLÈ’s interest
has not been limited to Makoko. An ambitious
research project, called ‘The African Water Cities
Project’ has also been set in place with the aim of
combining international expertise on water
management with local & indigenous techniques, to
create innovative, sustainable, urban solutions for
adaptation and resilience to climate change, in Africa
and beyond. Starting in Makoko with the support of
hbs, UNDP/Federal Ministry of the Environment &
AAP, NLÉ has taken action and completed a
prototype, the Makoko Floating School, in March
2013. A period of testing and evaluation followed its
construction, from April to September 2013, while its
official operation as an education venue is expected
before the end of this year. While the first step towards
rapid change has been thus completed, the ‘African
Water Cities Project’, is currently seeking funding and
strategic partnerships to further its research and
findings in the other parts of Nigeria and across
Africa, where hundreds of other waterfront
communities and major coastal cities
remain vulnerable.
Since its completion, the performance of Makoko
Floating School has been celebrated as an example of
a progressive approach to climate resilience and
adaptation for waterfront cities and communities in
Africa and beyond. It has been acknowledged as a
contemporary example of sustainable urban
development and building design, receiving
overwhelming support from international and national
academics, policy makers, journalists and cultural
commentators. NLÉ’s research has particularly
had light shed onto, by its
founder’s, Kunlé Adeyemi, invitation to present at
“Bearing the Brunt of Environmental Change:
Understanding Climate Adaptation and
Transformation Challenges in African Cities”. It was
where many academics and policy makers spoke in
The essence of Makoko offers
challenges yet solutions to the
problems of overprized land,
housing shortage and flooding
Towards Climate Resilience in Africa’s Water Cities
By Kunle Adeyemi and Lisa Anderson
Kunlé Adeyemi, Founder
and CEO of NLÉ is an
architect, designer and
‘urbanist’ with a track
record of conceiving and
completing high profile,
high quality projects
internationally
With a first degree in
International Relations
and a Masters in Human
Rights, Lisa Anderson
has worked for over ten
years managing large
scale projects with
charities, public sector
organizations and private
businesses.
30
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
support of new approaches to climate change
resilience in the face of urbanization and
underdeveloped, poorly resourced adaptation
policies and planning frameworks across Africa.
Furthermore, Makoko Floating School has employed
locally sourced and adaptive technologies to create
sustainable and empowering design solutions. It's
design and production methodology have been
acknowledged in reputable media and magazines, such
as the Architectural Review, Abitare, Harvard Gazette,
New York Times, CNN Inside Africa and The UK
Guardian, to mention a few. Nonetheless, the most
striking of all has been the School’s outstanding socio-
economic impact. NLÉ has provided the Makoko
community with a safe and enjoyable structure to
serve as a community meeting point and a cultural
platform, while placing education in the social focus.
Its iconic and functional design has made it a
recognizable landmark in Lagos state and a growing
identity and voice for the community, while stressing
the importance of climate resilience solutions. It has
acted as a live demonstration of NLÈ’s view that
community empowerment is key factor in sustainable
urbanization towards poverty eradication. As the
United Nations Human Settlements Programme, UN-
HABITAT, emphasizes
“Sustainable Urban
Development cannot be achieved without the active
involvement, participation and empowerment of
citizens and communities.”3
NLÉ’s efforts have been endorsed by the UN Habitat
through its invitation to participate at the international
Tripartite conference on “sustainable Urbanization as
Response to Urban Poverty Eradication”, which
highlighted the importance of climate
resilience towards a robust, strategic and truly
sustainable development approach for any African
city. Particularly, individuals such as Paul Okunlola,
architect and Programme Officer of the UN Habitat
Nigeria, and Ade Mamonyane Lekoetje, Nigeria’s
director of the UN Development Programme,
expressed their personal support to NLÉ, with their
presence at the School’s pre-launch event. In her
words, the project “serves a model to transform other
coastal communities in the West African region”.
Makoko Floating School’s replicability and scalability
has also been acknowledged through country and
continent wide interest in developing iterative
solutions that are indigenous, adaptable and mobile
for other waterfront communities, such as at the Delta
State. This first indigenous iteration is an
ongoing participatory design process of an
'amphibious building' - a community radio station - for
a waterfront community in Port Harcourt, Rivers state.
This new building will host a cultural, educational and
community media platform, called Chicoco Radio.
Moreover, the challenges that Makoko Floating
School Project has responded to and faced has been
even more variant than the ones mentioned.
Developing climate resilient strategies for waterfront
communities requires considerable innovation and
expertise on a state level as well.
“A legislative
framework that
“emphasises good governance,
responsibility, leadership and practical initiatives for
local governments, communities and citizens” must be
employed to reach such a goal.4 The project has
therefore depicted the complexity of the policy
landscape in Nigeria, since it required the state
government to be convinced to offer support and
be engaged in a meaningful manner in the process.
As Lagos State Government designated the area
of its waterfront as imperative of development, the
informal settlement of Makoko recently faced short
notice eviction. The design, participatory process and
research initiated by NLÉ has challenged the standards
of what sustainable development, climate change
resilience and adaptation solutions mean for Lagos
state. Overall, Makoko Floating School has also
suggested a new development strategy that responds to
The local residents have adapted
their lifestyle, to build and live
on water, forming an aquatic
city - a civilization on water
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
31
the increasing problem of land reclamation due to
climate change and has proposed an innovative
approach to spatial planning on water, while setting
the base for creative engagement of the government
authorities in such sustainable efforts.
However, Makoko Floating School was not
only destined as an innovation for addressing
challenges of urbanization and climate change
problems but more importantly as a means to stress the
need for a rounded and interdisciplinary approach and
thinking to urban planning and policy making. It
encourages the integration of a variety of fields’
expertise, such as in transportation, energy, sanitation
and water management policies. In the words of Lagos
State Governor, Babatunde Fashola, at the 5th Lagos
Climate Change Summit, “it is a war we need to fight
together and I am sure that if we fight together, the
human civilization will win, climate change is not
new, what is new is our knowledge about it and what
we do about it’’. Makoko Floating School has
therefore achieved to stress the necessity the State
Government has to provide the private sector an
enabling environment to aggressively pursue
mitigation and adaptation initiatives in the interest of
green development5. As it has later been stated at the
5th Lagos State Climate Change Summit “To properly
mainstream climate change into infrastructural
development there is need for infrastructural policy
development, legislation, planning and plan
implementation with effective private sector
participation” (13-15th March, 2013).
As far as the impact of the research project of ‘African
Water Cities’ is concerned, NLÉ has received
worldwide academic and individual
interest. NLÉ’s invited participation at
the MoMA biannual exhibition and workshop, as part
of one of the research teams, has been a highlight and
opportunity. The workshop and exhibition titled
“Uneven Growth” seeks to challenge current
assumptions about the relationships between formal
Aerial view of
Makoko and
the floating
school by
NLE
32
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
and informal, bottom-up and top-down urban
development”6 where the possibilities of progressive
and sustainable urban planning in partnership with
international urban planners are discussed and
investigated. Currently the body and interest of the
research continues and grows to include more cities
and communities, such as Luanda, Angola; Ganvié,
Benin; Capetown, South Africa; as well as Nzulenzu,
Ghana; attracting partnerships with parties sharing
similar interest in progressive responses to climate
change resilience in African cities.
The primary focus of NLÈ’s research and Floating
School project has been to contribute to climate
change resilient strategies. To start with, this has been
achieved by the project’s inherent community
empowerment and capacity building practice. Makoko
Floating School aimed not only to empower the
community with skills, but also allowed locals to
directly engage with other project partners and
stakeholders e.g. UNDP, Heinrich Boll Foundation,
Lagos State Government representatives. That way the
local culture of living and working on water was
introduced to an extensive interaction with an
empowering platform of stakeholders and partners
who can further enable plans for future community
development. More importantly, however, the
participatory design process involved the
understanding and integration of local expertise. The
floating school was built with locally available
materials, labour and vernacular building techniques
that were combined with existing relevant global
technologies. This integrative approach resulted in the
creation of a building fully responsive to the needs of
an aquatic environment. Furthermore, local knowledge
of environmental and climatic patterns, such as tidal
variations and rainfall patterns, as well as economic
and industrial potential of local aqua cultures, such as
fish farming, provided the necessary insights into the
project’s context. As described by the UN definition,
This integrative approach
resulted in the creation of a
building fully responsive to
the needs of an aquatic
environment
Makoko
Floating
School
courtesy hbs
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
33
‘sustainability implies responsibility for the social,
environmental and economic needs of the present
without compromising opportunities for future
generations’.7 The community’s involvement not only
in the conceptual development but also construction
and on-going maintenance of the building therefore
represented the essence of sustainable urban
development, enabling the local community to
replicate and further adapt the design of the building to
meet their present and future needs.
Makoko Floating School as a space for the community
NLÉ’s vision for Makoko and all waterfront
communities around Africa and
beyond remains optimistic and challenging.
This vision is tied to our hopes for deepening
our ‘African Water Cities’ Project research
body, in view of upscaling current findings
and achievements beyond the fishing
community of Makoko. Interdisciplinary
approach, design innovation, bridging
intellect as well as indigenous
knowledge stand in the heart of NLÉ’s core
ideologies. In the words of NLÉ
founder, Kunlé Adeyemi, “the overarching
aim of the practice is to bridge critical gaps in
infrastructure and urban development by
creating coherent networks and global
exchanges that work for people … whether a
chair for charity in South Africa, a
revolutionary rotating art space for Prada in Seoul or a
visionary plan [with OMA] to eliminate traffic
paralysis in Lagos, in each project the essential needs
of performance, value or identity – critical for success
- are fundamentally the same for me.” In order for
NLÉ's visions to generate real life changes for Makoko
and Lagos, state level resourcing and imminent
announcement about plans for Makoko must take
place. Once these measures occur the conversation
about sustainable development and climate resilience
planning for waterfront communities in Lagos will
then be able to move forward.
END NOTES
1
Steer, Andrew,
‘World Bank Special Envoy for Climate Change’,
<http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/AFRICAEXT/0,,contentMDK:22905780~menuPK:2246551~pagePK:2865
106~piPK:2865128~theSitePK:258644,00.html/> [accessed 15 November 2011]
2
NLÈ Shaping the Architecture of the Developing Cities,
‘Makoko Floating School Project Report’, available for download
<https://www.dropbox.com/sh/xps3t2gln49wpdz/lIIcPAqMFS> (April 2010)
3
Community Development Unit (CDU) (UN-Habitat For a Better Urban Future Website),
<http://mirror.unhabitat.org/categories.asp?catid=829> [accessed 12 December 2013]
4
Cities and Climate Change Initiative: (The UN-Habitat For a Better Urban Future Website),
<http://www.mirror.unhabitat.org/content.asp?cid=10192&catid=550&typeid=24&subMenuId=0> [accessed 12 December 2013]
5
‘Recommendations’, 5th Lagos State Climate Change Summit Communiqué (Summit theme of ‘Vulnerability and adaptability to climate
change in Nigeria: Lagos State transportation, housing and infrastructural sectors in focus’), p.6
6
Uneven Growth: Tactical Urbanisms for Expanding Megacities is organized by The Museum of Modern Art, New York, in collaboration with
the Museum of Applied Arts (MAK), Vienna.
7
Kunlé Adeyemi and Ore Disu, “Floating City Solutions for Africa’s Vulnerable Coastal Communities: The Case of Makoko”, Perspectives
Political analysis and commentary from Africa, 3.12 (2012), p. 18-23
Water City in
Lagos -
Makoko from
the air by
NLE
34
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Makoko Children
on the water, by
Fabulous Urban
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
35
The global debate on climate change is no longer
confined
to
purely
environmental
issues;
environmental goals are now more closely linked to
development
goals
leading
to
social
benefits
and
economic
growth.
Engaging
in
climate
change
adaptation activities in African countries must be seen as
supporting
the
achievement of certain development
goals
that
address
issues
such
as
environmental
degradation and improved livelihoods.
The
focus
of
Community
Conservation
and
Development
Initiatives’
(CCDI)
is
that people are
central to the sustainable use of natural resources and
environmental
protection.
Mainstreaming
climate
activities into the development process could potentially
generate new opportunities in terms of technological
innovation and creation of sustainable green jobs in key
sectors.
Climate change preparedness or adaptation strategies
can
help
reduce
the
risk
of
harm
to
vulnerable
communities by building resilience to its impacts. Local
governments have a critical role, because they are in
close proximity to communities, and through service
delivery
should
be
able
to
implement
policy
interventions which can strengthen sectors to minimise
climate risks.
Apart from South Africa, there is scant information
about the activities of local governments on climate
action
in
Africa. Climate change
is
likely
to
have
negative impacts but there are also positive gains to be
had; there are opportunities for local governments in
Nigeria to ensure their areas benefit from climate change
adaptation activities, which can bring economic gains.
Sectors of
the
local
economy
that
could enable a
reduction
in
resource use and energy consumption
(thereby strengthening resilience
to climate change)
include energy; food security; transport and water and
waste management. Interventions in these sectors could
reduce
greenhouse
gas
emissions
and
minimize
environmental risks according to local circumstances.
Mobilising Local Governments for Climate Action
In
2010,
under
the
Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung
Environmental
Governance
programme,
CCDI
implemented
the Mobilising Local Governments for
Climate Action Project, aimed at filling an identified gap
and raising awareness on climate change activities at
grassroots/community level in three local governments
in Lagos State. During the third stage of the project
(which covered practical activities on energy efficiency;
waste management and recycling; disaster management
and
food
security),
the
need
for
private
sector
involvement was repeatedly raised.
A series of demonstrations of fuel efficient stoves aimed
to build capacity around gender-related concerns, along
with an intervention that could reduce the effects of
global warming, improve health and generate economic
activity.
About
95
million
people
in
Nigeria,
representing 67% of the population depend on wood for
cooking daily, predominantly through the traditional
open fire method. This results in about 90% of energy
loss,
and
is
especially
dangerous
to
women
and
children’s health, sometimes causing deaths.1
The Nigerian Alliance for Clean Stoves was formed to
see why the clean cook stove market was not working.
Supported
by
Nigerian
and
international
NGOs,
including the Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung and the public and
private
sectors,
it
embarked
on
several
advocacy
initiatives
and
established
a
relationship
with
the
international
clean
cook
stove
community.
The
campaigns bore fruit when information on cook stoves
that were commercially obtainable in Nigeria became
available; previously most of the information was just
about prototypes.
Climate Resilience as a Growth Opportunity for Lagos Local
Governments
By Kofo Adeleke
Kofo Adeleke is
Director of
Programmes at
Community
Conservation and
Development
Initiatives (CCDI)
in Nigeria
36
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Separately,
under
the
‘Local
Urban Responses
to
Climate Change in Three Local Government Areas of
Lagos project’ CCDI organised fuel efficient stove
demonstrations with commercial stove vendors that had
been part of the Cook Stove Alliance.
Across Eti-Osa, Lekki and Yaba local governments 150
women tested stoves by cooking. A female community
leader said: “We are very grateful for the exposure this
has given us; to cook [with] stoves that will save us time
and money, create less smoke and be better for the
environment.”
The
women
were
also
informed
about
business
opportunities
available
through
buying
the
stoves
wholesale and becoming part of the Carbon Credit
Network. Expansion of informal lending schemes is a
prerequisite for wider stove dissemination
in areas
where
incomes
are
low,
and
an
improved
stove
represents a large investment. Also, the standardization
of
the
firewood-saving stove design enables mass
production, creating further economic opportunities.
Therefore,
financial
support
for
private
sector
initiatives
would
ensure
increased
investments
in
improved stove production.
Waste Management
Yaba Local Government has a high population and a
substantial lagoon coastline. Its challenges are similar
to the majority of local governments in Lagos: a rising
population, pressures on waste management,
traffic
congestion, public health and sanitation issues, and a
lack of open spaces. For Yaba, waste management is a
priority area for action.
In Lagos
the
link between
flooding, especially
in
vulnerable areas populated by low-income groups and
poor
waste
management practices
has
been
well
established. Action on waste management aims
to
reduce the environmental risks of flood damage, which
would protect community assets, providing a healthier
environment and economic benefits.
CCDI contacted the Lagos State Waste Management
Authority (LAWMA) and reached an agreement
to
place a waste separation bank for recycling in the local
government secretariat, as a demonstration to the wider
community. LAWMA is the agency responsible for
collection and disposal of municipal and
industrial
waste. It provides commercial waste services in the
State and its local governments. This centralisation of
responsibility
developed
when
waste
became
increasingly difficult for individual local government
councils to manage.
A workshop was held in September 2012 to explain the
purpose of the waste
bank
and
the
importance
and
benefits
of
recycling.
Participants
learnt
about
the
market
which
exists
for
waste
products,
creates jobs and also
protects
the
environment
simultaneously.
We are very grateful for the
exposure this has given us; to
cook [with] stoves that will save
us time and money, create less
smoke and be better for the
environment
High Efficiency
Green Cooking
stove in use, by
Yahaya Ahmed
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
37
Yaba’s
local
government
chairman
responded
positively, and said at the time: “There is a high level of
unemployment
among
young
people
locally
and
definitely there are economic opportunities for them in
waste
products.”
He
instructed
all
staff
to
start
separating recyclable materials and begin immediate
use of the new waste bank.
An outcome of this workshop was a real demand to
demonstrate
the
economic opportunities
for
waste
management within the communities. A knowledge gap
needed to be filled regarding business potential and the
identification of key areas where private sector activity
could
take
place,
thereby
creating
employment
opportunities
for
skilled
and
unskilled
residents.
Strategies could then be developed for communities to
create
income-generating
businesses
from
waste
management, with support from the local government
and
possibly
LAWMA
-
both
of
which
could
implement regulations and policies to encourage locally
based waste management initiatives.
Developing Green Business Opportunities for Local
Economies
A new project activity area was embarked upon, the
goal being that practical policy recommendations for
climate resilient economic growth, income generation
and environmental protection in Yaba local government
should result.
CCDI organised a stakeholders’ mapping exercise in
June 2013 to determine levels of vulnerability to waste
management challenges. CCDI met with officials from
Yaba’s environmental health department who make
assessments and report on waste management issues in
communities. Initially the reports were that Yaba did
not have the type of waste dump-sites where resource
recoverers, commonly known as ‘scavengers’ operate.
However, when CCDI visited health centres within
different communities, officials
identified
the areas
with the biggest waste challenges.
An
environmental
health
officer
who
covers
the
Makoko area said: “Some of the areas of Makoko are
on water and the waste management issues are more of
a
challenge but we are
trying
to
work with
the
community and relevant bodies to find ways of dealing
with it.”
Another responsible for the Iwaya area believed that
roads are implicated in inefficient waste collection:
“Some of the roads are either in very poor condition or
extremely narrow and
this means
that
the garbage
trucks cannot reach certain areas of the community.”
CCDI found a community
called Ajoke located on the
edge of the Lagos lagoon, out
of which cart pushers
operated. The whole
community was built on about
9 feet of waste, accumulated
over about 20 years.
Waste build-up at
the waterside of
Lagos Lagoon, by
Aderemi Adegbite
38
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
These most vulnerable areas were visited and key
stakeholders identified. They include: members of the
community
development
council;
community
development
association
(CDA)
leaders;
informal
private sector operators involved in waste recovery;
traditional leaders and private sector participation waste
operators (PSPs). Consultations were held to review
stakeholder relationships and existing service models in
waste collection in the communities. Although the cart
pushers who go from house to house collecting waste
have been officially banned by LAWMA they still
operate
surreptitiously,
usually
under
cover
of
darkness.
The
mapping
exercise
often
became
a
problem-solving
one,
as
stakeholders
used
the
opportunity to recount their inability to dispose of waste
properly.
From this mapping exercise three areas with distinct
waste management challenges were identified: Igbobi
Sabe, Iwaya, and Makoko. In order to adopt a bottom-
up approach for knowledge sharing and gain first-hand
interaction with stakeholders, focal group discussions
were held in the communities.
Igbobi Sabe
Two communities - Abule Oja and Abule Ijesha - where
the
terrain
is
more
difficult
to
navigate
have
experienced
problems
with
accumulated
and
uncollected waste. An abandoned residential structure
was converted into a huge dumping site by residents in
Abule Ijesha . The main issues were that the PSPs did
not remove waste for long periods of time, problems of
inaccessible roads and the inability of some residents to
pay for waste collection.
Iwaya
Although the PSPs are assigned to work here, illegal
cart pushers serve Iwaya, as the condition of many
roads prevent garbage trucks from plying them.
Many of
the cart pushers were unwilling
to speak
publicly for fear of the authorities.
“We get harassed from the local authorities when we try
to do our business; sometimes we just have to operate
in the late evening or at night,” a cart pusher explained.
Iwaya has also endured serious drainage problems.
CCDI found a community called Ajoke located on the
edge of the Lagos lagoon, out of which cart pushers
operated. The whole community was built on about 9
feet
of
waste,
accumulated over about 20 years.
Residents said they no longer needed waste to fill the
land but wanted
the
government
to
install
proper
drainage
systems,
as
during
heavy
rainfall
Ajoke
becomes impassable and awash with floating waste.
Some
land was being used
for waste sorting and
collection, with access granted only because we were
escorted
by
the
head
of
the
local
community
development association. The leader of the cart pushers
showed us the yard, where CCDI examined plastics,
paper, cans metals, batteries, aluminium and rubber
being sorted.
Makoko
Spontaneous
Waste dumping
on an empty plot
in Igbobi area
Lagos, by CCDI
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
39
In Lagos, Makoko is often mentioned as a target for
slum upgrading and urban renewal by organisations
like
the
World
Bank,
and
several
NGOs
have
intervened, aiming to work out more equitable and
sustainable solutions to
Makoko’s problems.2
In terms of a long term strategy the situation is quite
complex.
Makoko’s peculiarity determined the reason to hold two
focal group discussions; one with an area known as
House on the Lagoon, where the entire community is
built
on collected waste dumped
into
the
lagoon.
Residents were extremely sensitive to strangers because
the state government has a pending case over
the
validity of the settlement and the environmental impact
it has on the wider area. The houses are in clusters, with
movement facilitated by narrow footpaths. Although
LAWMA has assisted the community by placing a
waste collection facility on the lagoon, residents are
well aware that a serious waste management problem
persists. One of the chiefs for the Makoko community
said: “When our fishermen go out on the water they are
now catching more water sachets and plastic bottles
than fish!” As this situation is causing their fishing nets
to
tear,
the community accepts
that an
inability
to
manage waste is directly affecting their livelihood.
The
second
focal
group
discussion
held
in
New
Makoko, which has experienced some upgrading and
new drainage. Some sites exist where people are
already engaged in buying waste products made from
metal and plastics; some of the items recovered were
also
undergoing
repair.
New Makoko
is
also
the
recipient of a recycling bank from LAWMA, which
residents said is hardly used; it was situated in a small
garden area which was fenced around, and under lock
and key.
Pinpointing Opportunities
Identifying suitable opportunities involves stakeholder
engagement about the best practical options. Based on
information
gathered
from
the
mapping exercises,
consultations and focal group discussions, work began
on developing individual business models for buy back
centres3
for
recyclables
for
each community. Key
proposals include:
●Sensitization programmes by the CDAs to inform
community members about how they can collect waste
to sell at the buy back centres.
●Recovered waste materials will include water sachets,
PET bottles, aluminium cans, metals, cardboard and
paper.
●Centres will be operated by local residents who will
buy
the
recovered waste,
repackage
it
and sell
to
recycling companies.
●A proposal was made for the existing recycling bank
at New Makoko to be converted into a buy back centre.
●More information and awareness needs to be created
about LAWMA’s buy back recycling truck.
●Abandoned plots and other empty spaces could be
used as buy back centres.
Public Sector Leadership and Private Finance
A number of policy suggestions have emerged from the
study,
which
will
be
discussed
with
Yaba
local
government executives, passed on to LAWMA, and
could create an enabling environment
for
income
generation. There is also scope for better integration of
policies between the local government and LAWMA.
The main challenges identified were land-use issues,
finance, adequate budgetary provision and weak local
government capacity regarding waste management, as
most of
the responsibility for waste collection and
disposal has been devolved to LAWMA.
Private sector capacity must be shored up
to
take
advantage of the supply and demand which exists for
different types of recyclable waste, which will provide
income generating opportunities for residents. Proper
mapping of areas and more statistical information about
waste generation in parts of Yaba would stimulate and
drive continued private involvement.
More dialogue is required between local governments,
LAWMA, the private sector and funding agents. Wider
Some of the roads are either in
very poor condition or
extremely narrow and this
means that the garbage trucks
cannot reach certain areas of
the community
40
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
stakeholders such as the financial sector have a real
influence in encouraging climate change resilience as
access to finance is essential to scale up locally based
opportunities
in waste management.
For example,
adequate vehicles are needed
to provide a
regular
service to collect the materials from the proposed buy
back centres. Financing options are needed for
the
private sector to acquire capital to set up businesses
which can collect and recycle valuable waste such as
plastic, paper and glass.
Towards Economic Empowerment and Climate
Resilience
More than ever, growth and sustainable development
rely on adapting to the effects of climate change and
protecting the natural habitat and its resources from
further
degradation.
Government
policies
will
be
crucial
for
stimulating
adaptation
planning
and
spending, especially in the area of spatial planning, to
encourage local waste recycling and disposal sites. It is
critical that investments are made in climate change
preparedness or adaptation measures. Also, substantial
input by the private sector to promote innovation and
financing
is
essential
to sustaining environmentally
friendly growth.
All
the challenges are
interconnected and call
for
simultaneous solutions through: integrated policies to
regulate
the
waste
sector,
appropriate
financing
choices, social dialogue and efficient cooperation.
These strategies can help reduce the risk of harm to
vulnerable communities by building resilience to the
impacts of climate change.
The communities CCDI engaged with
were enthusiastic about exchanging
their waste for cash, and willing to
help implement best practices in their
locality. Opportunities exists for all
councils in Lagos to ensure their local
areas
benefit
from
this
source
of
economic growth.
Much
work
is
still
needed
on
changing
behavioural
patterns
and
attitudes to waste, as these can play a large part in the
adoption or rejection of any new waste management
practice.
The process of change is made easier, and is more
constructive
when
communities
are
practically
involved in the process of their own development and
empowered to mobilise their own capacities.
The communities CCDI
engaged with were enthusiastic
about exchanging their waste
for cash
END NOTES:
1
‘Urbanisation and the Choice of Fuel Wood as a Source of Energy in Nigeria’ Y.Y. Babanyara and U. F. Saleh Accessed via:
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1876733
2
In 2006 the World Bank started the Lagos Metropolitan Development and Governance Project with the Lagos State government, which was
an urban slum upgrading project and Makoko was one of nine settlements in Lagos classified as blighted areas. Included among the NGOs
that have intervened to try to work out more equitable and sustainable solutions in the Makoko area are the Social and Economic Right
Action Centre, Urban Spaces Innovation, Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung, as well as CCDI.
3
A buy back centre receives and buys recyclables recovered from general waste from the local area it is situated in. An individual or
entrepreneur, possibly empowered from the local community, can operate the centre. The operator will buy recovered waste materials like
plastics (pure water sachets, PET bottles from all drinks), Aluminium cans, metals, cardboard papers etc in sufficient quantities from local
residents, and re-package them to sell to recycling companies that utilize recovered waste that can be turned into other products.
Recyclable Waste
materials for
proposed waste buy-
back scheme
courtesy CCDI
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
41
Plastics
waste
recycling plant at
Olusosun
Lagos,
byReinvent Media
42
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Discarded
Computer
parts, courtesy
Green Cycle
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
43
As the most populous city and the economic centre
of West Africa, Lagos’ journey towards climate
resilience is of vital importance to Nigeria and the
region’s future. There is a dramatic shift occurring in
Africa towards urbanization and industrialization, and
Lagos is at the forefront of this change. This rapid
economic and population growth brings with it many
issues
of
sustainability.
There
is
an
increasing
consumption of resources leading to ever higher levels
of
pollution
and
hazardous
waste,
which
has
a
significant impact on environmental and public health.
The World Health Organization estimates that 33% of
the global burden of disease for children is attributable
to the environment.
Industrial pollutants are the main
cause of this ecological damage.
Electronic waste is the fastest growing waste stream in
the world. By 2017 it is estimated that Africa will
generate more e-waste than the EU, with Nigeria being
the largest producer on the continent. E-waste contains
heavy metals such as lead and mercury as well as other
toxic
substances
which
all
carry
potential
for
environmental contamination. Dangerous practices in
the informal recycling sector such as open burning and
dumping exacerbate the problem. Electronic waste also
contains many materials including precious and rare
earth
metals
that
are
impossible
to
extract
using
informal recycling techniques, meaning that informal
recycling is highly inefficient as well as dangerous.
Without awareness of the damage that these practices
cause, hazardous wastes will increasingly cause public
health issues in the future.
Nigerian e-waste production is estimated at 1.1 million
tonnes annually and Lagos produces a large proportion
of this waste and has 4 markets where the informal
e-waste sector operates, spreading out the damage and
also posing more widespread risk. The amount is not a
surprise
given
that
there
is
increasing
access
to
information
and
communication
technology
.
Electronic equipment is penetrating the homes of many
Nigerians, from mobiles, televisions and computers to
fridges and generators. It is one of the fastest growing
markets
in
Nigeria.
For
example,
according
to
Wikipedia Nigeria is ranked Ninth in the world for
Mobile Phone usage with over 167 million registered
units
as
at
February
2014.
The
United
Nations
Environment programme (UNEP)has established that
91% of used electronic imports into Nigeria are re-used
and that 85% of the e-waste present in dumpsites is
generated
domestically.
The
problem
of
illegal
importation of end-of-life electronic equipment has
been over-stated. The reality is that everything that can
be refurbished or re-used is utilised and this provides
affordable 2nd hand electronics to the majority, helping
to bridge the digital divide. The real issue that is arising
is that domestic production is expected to increase 8%
per year for the next 3 years. Without formalised e-
waste recycling development, Nigeria will be facing
huge quantities of electronic waste and
far bigger
problems later on.
There
are
more
than
20
heavy
metals
found
in
electronics but four are of particular concern to human
health: lead (Pb), cadmium (Cd), mercury (Hg), and
inorganic arsenic (As). According to the U.S. Agency
for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, these four
heavy metals are four of the top six hazards present in
toxic waste sites. They are highly toxic and can cause
damaging effects even at very low concentrations.
However, individuals carrying out basic retrieval have
barely any
idea of
the dangers
they are exposing
themselves and their communities too. Children and
youths are exploited by those that on-sell the waste
undertake much of this hazardous work in appalling
conditions.
In
independent
research
by
Olayemi
Adesanya in 2011 on behalf of Greenpeace, the Basel
Action Network, the BBC and CNN, he concluded that
the majority of Lagos residents handling e-waste are
between the ages of 10 – 19. Incredibly, there are higher
numbers under the age of 10 than of those between 30
Electronic Waste in Lagos – An Opportunity or a looming Environmental and
Health Disaster?
By George Richards
George Richards is the
co-founder of Green
Cycle, a social
enterprise
aiming to use waste
management to raise
awareness and tackle
environmental and
public health issues in
Lagos. An
environmentalist and
a frequent visitor to
Nigeria from a young
age, including
spending time
volunteering in the
Cross River rainforest
44
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
– 39 years of age. The majority have been dealing with
e-waste for 3 years or less and none belong to a trade
association. Of these he also found that:
92% are unaware that e-waste poses a hazard to human
health
84% are unaware of any
regulation or
legislation
concerning e-waste management in Lagos state.
95% use open burning as a method of recovering
materials from e-waste.
In addition, the majority eat vegetables grown on and
around dumpsites, eat meat from animals that feed on
dumpsites
and
drink
water
drawn
from
wells
or
boreholes situated close to dumpsites. Despite this,
many of those working with electronic waste report job
satisfaction and claim that it adds value to their lives.
Although
e-waste
is
generating
employment
and
helping to alleviate poverty in Lagos State, the sector
is informal, unorganized, uninformed and illiterate with
no
implemented
regulation.
The
electronic
waste
business is lucrative and contributes to the informal
economy, but without an awareness of the health risks
it poses or laws to regulate the sector, informal workers
are putting themselves at risk. It is critical that further
research is conducted for heavy metal contamination of
groundwater and food grown local to these sites.
Failure
to comprehensively address
the dangers of
hazardous waste and pollution now will
inevitably
create serious environmental and public health risks in
the future. Resource and waste management is the most
direct area in which we can tackle these problems.
Presently Lagos State Waste management Authority
LAWMA has the overwhelming task of collecting all of
Lagos’ municipal solid waste, the logistical complexity
of this restricts their ability to effectively manage the
waste they collect and no segregation takes place. In
order to improve waste management in Lagos, there
needs to be specialisation and diversification in the
industry
so
that
separate waste categories can be
managed separately and be utilised. The material that
LAWMA collects currently includes organic wastes,
recyclables and even toxic wastes all together, all taken
to landfill.
Cross-contamination means
that
recycling becomes
expensive and difficult and because
there
are
no
sanitary landfills, any toxic material being collected is
still left exposed to the environment. Meanwhile, the
recycling industry in Nigeria is in its infancy. There is
progress being made, in plastics and tyre recycling for
example, however, more investment and development
in private sector waste management is needed.
Effective waste management and resource efficiency
are
not
only
beneficial
in
curbing
environmental
damage and building climate resilience, they form the
core of sustainable economy. The economic potential of
waste
reduction
and
resource
recovery
and
the
development of a ‘circular’ economy took centre stage
at Davos earlier this year. (The circular economy is a
generic
term for an
industrial economy
that
is, by
design or
intention,
restorative and
in which used
materials are re-cycled for secondary or similar use.)
A
report released at the annual meeting claims that
the
Personal Computer
recycling in Lagos,
courtesy of Green Cycle
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
45
The future lies in circular
economies in which resources are
never lost.
build-up of circular supply chains that increase the rate
of recycling, reuse and remanufacture could generate
more than $1 trillion a year for the global economy by
2025.The report, by the World Economic Forum and the
Ellen MacArthur Foundation, calls for companies
to
understand the opportunities available through a circular
business model and that innovations in shared value,
resource efficiency, circular economy, new consumption
models
and
transparency/customer
engagement
are
needed in order for companies to profit from delivering
environmental and social value. Speaking at the World
Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, the CEO of
Philips, Frans Van Houten, said that his company now
sees the circular economy as "a way to make a giant leap
forward" in terms of interlinking smarter resource use
with profitability. Houten stated that “there is more gold
coming out of e-waste than actually out of the mines”.
Recovering resources from electronic waste represents
the massive potential of moving towards
‘closing the
loop’
Clearly it is not only Lagos’s environment but also its
economy
that
can
profit
from
solving
the
e-waste
problem.
The Orile Iganmu Scheme
Green Cycle is a project that aims to become the first
sustainable e-waste
recycler
in
Nigeria. There
is
a
significant financial opportunity
in e-waste recycling
that
is
currently
being overlooked. A modern and
efficient recycling industry can tackle growing resource
issues as well as environmental and public health issues.
Providing
not
only
an
eco-friendly
but
profitable
solution to Lagos’ e-waste problem can give rise to a
sustainable future industry for Nigeria. Industry can line
up with climate resilience, a true model for the future of
a climate friendly megacity. The best practice for global
e-waste recycling is the “Best of 2 Worlds” model.
Complex electrical components usually contain
the
precious
metals
and
rare-earth
elements
that
are
becoming more and more valuable, but also contain the
dangerous materials that can only be processed safely in
a few state-of-the-art facilities globally. However, there
is a large part of the recycling process in the developed
world that is inefficient, expensive and energy intensive.
E-waste recycling plants in Europe and the US separate
the materials in electronic equipment by shredding and
sorting. They essentially smash everything up and then use a
variety of techniques such as magnets and laser sensors to
filter back out the desired materials. The costs of labour in the
US and Europe mean
that
recycling companies
require
capital intensive facilities just to separate the material, before
any recycling process can begin. This process generally
achieves a recovery rate of less than 60%. Separation is most
efficient when e waste is manually dismantled rather than
shredded and sorted using expensive machinery. Not only are
the costs minimized but also
the
recovery
rate
is
also
significantly higher at just under 90%. In the
“Best of 2
Worlds” model, developing nations are able to provide a
superior service. Manual dismantling uses little energy whilst
achieving a high recovery rate, and most
importantly
it
provides the opportunity for large-scale employment.
So a simple model that pre-processes and partially recycles
electronics can be effective and can boost local industries, in
a sustainable way. However, there is a much larger challenge
in solving our e-waste problem and that is the collection of
e-waste and preventing it from going to landfill or being
dumped. Domestic production of e-waste
is
spread out.
Implementing a unified collection scheme on a household
basis across Lagos, let alone Nigeria, would entail huge costs
and is not feasible, especially due to ineffective infrastructure.
Localised and independent collection schemes managed
through Community Development Associations (CDAs) are
an alternative and effective way of collecting waste and
prevent dumping at
relatively
low cost. This must be
reinforced by community involvement, raising awareness
and educating the populace on the issues surrounding public
health dangers of hazardous waste. Green Cycle believes that
solutions must be developed from the bottom-up in line with
socio-economic
factors.
Rather
than
importing
and
attempting to forcefully implement a solution, the focus will
be on capacity building, directly working with communities
to
co-develop
sustainable
enterprises
around
e-waste
collection. Green Cycle will pilot this model within Orile
Iganmu alongside the Orile Iganmu Progressive Association
(OIPA) it can then be replicated by other CDAs.
46
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
OIPA is a CDA that seeks to empower the community of
Orile Iganmu. Its main activity is an IT literacy and web
design programme that provides many young people in
the community, previously without the qualifications or
experience
to
find
work,
an
opportunity
to
find
employment.
Information
and
communications
technology play a huge role in development and teaching
the youth in these low-income communities how to gain
from
these
technologies builds a
foundation
for
the
generation that will need to find employment.
With
35%
unemployment
in
Nigeria’s
under
30
population, educating the youth to utilise technology for
personal development is critical. Learning to effectively
deal with e-waste would also broaden the opportunities for
learning and empowerment and bring a more holistic
understanding of technology.
A Waste Management programme
that
would
raise
awareness of the dangers of hazardous waste and teach
how
to safely handle
these wastes would be widely
beneficial. Also showing how to minimise, re-use and
recycle waste would significantly improve the sanitation
and living conditions of the local community.
Waste must be viewed as a resource. We operate in a
linear economy in which we pour vast amount of resource
into one end and afterwards it falls out of the other, often
with devastating effect. To build a truly climate resilient
megacity we must become a circular economy. Rather
than 2nd electronics exports to the developing world being
seen as ‘exporting harm’, we believe that it can be seen in
a radically more positive light by efficiently drawing
those resources into the Nigerian economy.
Professor Margaret Bates, a leading international expert
(Head
of
Waste
Management,
University
of
Northampton) summaries this clearly:
“Having
spent
time
in
Nigeria helping
to
train
the
informal sector, and other key stakeholders, in the risks
and
opportunities
of
waste
recycling
the
importance of initiatives such as Green Cycle
is clear. There are calls across the EU to ban
all imports of second hand goods to Africa but
this fails to recognise the role that second hand
ICT can play in the development of a country.
My good friend Professor Osibanjo has stated
that the role of second hand ICT cannot be
underestimated in the development of Africa,
in places 80-90% of people cannot afford new
equipment. We need to ensure that access to
new ICT does not mean only the rich explore
the opportunities presented by the digital economy. It is
vital to involve communities in developments, it is their
future that is being ensured and they must benefit from the
opportunities rather than suffering the consequences. In
the UK, and other Western countries, much has been
made of the waste problem but now is the time to focus
on the waste solution.”
References:
1.
Adesanya, O - Effect of Electronic waste on the Health and Socio-Economic life of the people of Lagos
2.
Blacksmith Institute & Green Cross Switzerland – Toxic threats top 10
3.
Ellen MacArthur Foundation – Towards the circular economy vol1
4.
Ellen MacArthur Foundation – Towards the circular economy vol2
5.
Ellen MacArthur Foundation – Towards the circular economy vol3
Used TV Screens
for sale or
disposal courtesy
Green Cycle
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
47
Mile 2, FESTAC, Snake lsland, Lagos-Badagry
Expressway and Trade Fair Complex. These
places named in metropolitan Lagos, often stigmatized
as traffic hazards, are embedded within the Amuwo-
Odofin Local Government Area. In a sense, residents of
Lagos State have come to expect a classic range of
symptoms associated with urban growth
–
rampant
vehicle accidents; floods, fires; congestion; collapse of
buildings; crime and disease; insufficient and inadequate
housing;forced
evictions
of
slum-dwellers
without
resettlement options and poor electricity and water
supply. Yet, the city’s status as a vibrant melting pot
provides important stimuli for strategic planning, in a
future
that
will
be
impacted
by
urbanization and climate change.
Hazards precede disasters,
the
latter
often
occurring
in
vulnerable
areas
where poor people have little defences.
Annual
floods
from
heavy
rainfall
constitute the major hazard in Amuwo-
Odofin,
closely
followed
by
poor
sanitation
through
inadequate
solid
waste
and
sewage
disposal,
then
unregulated traffic, leading to frequent
road accidents.
Difficulties
in
the
management
of
disasters in Lagos are contingent on 3
factors: (a) influx of people into the
megacity, (b) an increase in extreme
weather
events
–
floods
and
ocean
surges, and (c) governance at the local
level. These irreversible perspectives of
economics and ecology emphasize the
existential
imperative
of
building
societal resilience, especially
through
good governance.
Disasters conjure up images of sudden, natural (e.g.
hurricanes, earthquakes) or man-made (fires, multiple
road accidents) events of a scale that result in loss of
lives and property. Governments spend a lot of money
hiring, training, and putting people in uniforms to fight
disasters. More efforts could be directed at achieving
coherence of those different facets of activity that can
collectively
forestall
the
escalation
of
hazards and
improve response to disasters when they occur. In the
field, we therefore adopted the approach that disaster
risk
management
must
also
include
policy
and
environmental conservation to prevent their incidence in
the first place.
Disaster Management in Amuwo-Odofin
By Ako Amadi
Ako Amadi, is a
Marine ecologist and
Founder/CEO,
Community
Conservation &
Development
Initiatives, (CCDI)
Contact:
akoamadi@gmail.com
Map of
Amuwo
Odofin in
Lagos State
courtesy
Google maps
48
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Created in 2003, Amuwo-Odofin is one of 57 local
government areas and is located—like most of Lagos—
on virtually drained coastal wetlands. This is one key to
its vulnerability to environmental and climate hazards.
Over
a
million
people
live
and
commute within
approximately 100 square kilometres that is unique in
having 5 kilometres of Atlantic coastline hemming in
less saline wetland areas. Badagry Creek, Porto Novo
Creek, and the Lagos-Badagry Expressway cut across
the mid-section of Amuwo-Odofin horizontally.
Proximity to the sea has attracted port facilities, fishing
settlements and the establishment of a naval base. A
growing
population
means
schools,
health-care
institutions,
recreation
facilities,
increased
urban
farming,
trade
in diverse goods and heavier
traffic.
Amuwo-Odofin
is a fragile zone. Human activity—
mainly dredging and drainage—has worsened coastal
erosion and the downward shift of the Earth’s surface in
relation to sea-level, a phenomenon that geophysicists
refer to as ‘subsidence.’
Shipping, urbanization, industrialization and therefore
transportation and environmental transformation have
spiraled in the last decades. Lagos is growing at 4.9%, as
against the annual population growth rate of 3.6% for
the rest of Nigeria. The World City Mayors association
ranks Lagos as the 7th fastest growing city in the world,
while the 2013 Climate Change Vulnerability Index
places
the
megacity
in
10th
position,
under
the
qualification: high risk!
The existing Lagos-Badagry Expressway is currently
being widened
to
ten
lanes, with construction of a
median light rail. Under sponsorship of the Lagos State
Metropolitan Area Transport Authority (LAMATA),
work started in 2010 on the initial ‘Blue Line,’ to run
from Marina to Okokomaiko at a projected cost of 70
billion
Naira,
and
undertaken
by
the
China Civil
Engineering Construction Company. Construction sites
are hazards in their own right. Additionally, work on the
Lagos-Badagry
Expressway
has
shaved
off
large
swathes of humid forest and mangroves in Amuwo-
Odofin.
Today, what is left of these invaluable natural systems is
harvested for firewood, and the spaces thereby created
turned into automobile scrap-yards and municipal waste
dump sites. Loss of mangroves and other water plants
eliminates a critical source of coastline stabilization and
destroys the nursery grounds for early life stages of fish
and shellfish.
This
opening up of
forests
through
indiscriminate
cutting encourages land grabbing, the decimation of
wildlife, opening the way for colonization by disease
vectors - mosquitoes and rats. It encourages the growth
of weeds, silting of natural and artificial waterways,
illegal construction of homes, factories, warehouses,
kiosks and shops, jetties, refuse dumping, erosion and
flooding. Water hyacinths and other invasive, aquatic
plants at Amuwo-Odofin indicate high pollution levels
from domestic, market and industrial waste.
Disasters: Between nature and man
FESTAC Town and its extension across the link bridge
off 1st Avenue are comparatively low density residential
areas. Much of upland Amuwo-Odofin is however choc-
a-bloc
full
of small-scale businesses, often next
to
churches and schools, but occupying paved strips built
to serve as walkways. Traffic through the adjacent Ojo
area, west of Amuwo-Odofin, with the State University,
Trade Fair Complex and Alaba International Market to
Badagry,
which
advances
into
the
neighbouring
maritime West African states,coupled with increased
population and economic growth,
turn
the
Mile 2
Junction
into a fortress of urban
immobility. There
hasn’t yet been an elixir to the problems of traffic at Mile
2, and not many flattering things are said about the
conduct of police or wardens at this landmark junction.
Low-cost housing schemes in Amuwo-Odofin like the
Jakande and Raji Rasaki Estates, as in much of Lagos
are erroneously conceived, i.e. without play grounds for
children and recreation for adults facilities and space for
home gardens – a buffer against food insecurity. Their
narrow verandas, separated from the street by mostly
It is not so much nature that
exposes Amuwo-Odofin to
weather-related hazards, but
man
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
49
uncovered gutters, clogged with garbage and plastic
shopping bags easily find conversion into market stalls
for diverse merchandise, which is often collected by
vendors for sales in a nearby traffic jam.
These situations could be avoided, or minimized
if
regulatory
mechanisms
are
put
in
place
through
education,
transparent
and
efficient
licensing,
enforcement and consequent prosecution of offenders.
Homes and offices store gas, gasoline, kerosene and
diesel.
Residents and workers barricade doors and
windows with what is popularly known as
“burglary
proof”. These protective structures equally prevent an
escape from fire and flood hazards. Thus, it is not so
much nature that exposes Amuwo-Odofin to weather-
related hazards, but man.
In a Heinrich Boll Foundation-sponsored lecture titled:
Climate Change and Conflict at the National Defence
College, Abuja, Dan Smith of the organization Climate
Alert
listed
three
components
of
vulnerability
–
exposure, sensitivity and adaptability. Coastal Lagos
raises fundamental issues of physical change, and has
therefore been repeatedly studied and published. More
recently, the subject has been discussed at national,
international and regional seminars and workshops on
sea-level rise and urban transformation. Global studies,
driven by A.C.Ibe, L.Awosika, R.Folorunsho of
the
Nigerian
Institute
for
Oceanography
and
Marine
Research, the US University of Maryland, UNESCO
and
UN-HABITAT
have
contributed
to
the
identification of the Lagos coastline both as a hot spot or
node of rapid coastal development and environmental
degradation; a system vulnerable
to
the
impacts of
climate change, specifically to sea-level rise and coastal
erosion.
Emeritus Professor of Medicine, University of Ibadan,
Nigeria, Oladipupo Akinkugbe believes
that Nigeria
lacks disaster preparedness, because such events in the
country have so far been minor in magnitude. “To have
an effective preparedness plan, there has to be a major
modification of our personal and institutional attitudes
towards response to disasters,” he said.
The concept of the local government in Nigeria, and
elsewhere
is
one
of
participatory,
decentralized
democracy – to bring people closer to governance and
get them involved in issues that affect the community.
Apart from anecdotal accounts, no documented records
of previous disasters exist in the Amuwo-Odofin local
government.
Today, what is left of these
invaluable natural systems
is harvested for firewood,
and the spaces thereby
created turned into
automobile scrap-yards
and municipal waste dump
sites.
Destruction of
forest for
expansion of
Badagry
expressway,by
Aderemi Adegbite
50
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
The Climate Change Unit of the Amuwo-Odofin Local
Government at FESTAC Town was established by law
in October, 2010, after a delegation participated at the
Copenhagen Climate Change Summit in 2009. Inspired
by the experience, Comrade Ayodele Adewale who is
the
Local
Government’s
Chairman, created a
first
climate unit mandated to carry out research, training and
advocacy in Lagos. This is an encouraging sign that
points to a gradual mainstreaming of climate concerns
and disaster risk reduction into development.
To counter the apathy towards planning for disasters and
record-keeping of related incidents, a Local Emergency
Management
Committee
(LEMC),
consisting
of
representatives from the fire service, the Police, the Red
Cross, schools, hospitals and other professional bodies
was
formed
as
a
“Help
Desk”
on
disaster
risk
management, and to suggest possibilities for innovative
solutions to urban decay. Such an advisory facility could
serve to disseminate basic information on best practices
- the use of energy appliances, storage of inflammable
fuel and cooking gas in homes; advising community
members on low carbon energy technology: wind and
solar installations, bio gas plants and energy-efficiency
retrofitting,
particularly
around
waste
management,
construction
and
transportation.
Private
sector
involvement is crucial, and the LEMC has the duty of
unlocking
the doors
to banks,
insurance companies,
manufacturers and venture businesses.
The
intention at Amuwo-Odofin
is
for
the Climate
Change Unit and the Local Emergency Management
Committee to forge productive relationships with the
older, established
institutions of waste management,
environment, traffic control and urban planning at the
state level, and also with the community development
associations (CDAs) and youth organizations of
the
local government, who could be
trained
in disaster
management.
Approaches
and
processes
pose
challenges that cannot be met by public servants in the
state and local government offices alone. It is imperative
to comprehend the vitality of participation by the entire
community, under
structured
public
awareness and
education activities on disaster reduction.
Climate Compatible Development Initiatives’ study had
two
complementary
objectives:
(a)
to
determine
strategic
perspectives
around
responses
to
environmental
hazards,
based
on
a
vulnerability
assessment of the area, and (b) working closely with the
Climate Change Unit within the Amuwo-Odofin Local
Government to construct a framework plan of action for
disaster management.
Our street
interviews at Amuwo-Odofin revealed
in
some cases a curious dislike to planning for disasters - a
cultural, and perhaps fatalistic view that disasters are
ordained
by
divine
intervention
to
punish
human
transgressions.“Look at all the bad things happening in
Nigeria today – corruption, kidnapping, 419 [advance-
fee fraud]. It is from that sort of thing, that this sort of
thing happens,” added an individual called Lawrence,
pointing to flooded homes after heavy rains.
“Only God will help us in this country!” muttered a
woman repeatedly at the disaster management workshop
organised
by
the
Climate
Change
Unit
for
the
community of Sagbokoji on the coast of Amuwo-Odofin.
The
need
for
environmentally-friendly
land
use
planning,
impact
assessments
and
audit,
house
construction and waste disposal guidelines cannot be
overemphasized. Rainwater and floodwater harvesting
are possible with minimal
technological application,
without
impairing groundwater
recharge.
A
simple
gutter of galvanized metal, attached to the perimeter of
a house roof collects rainwater that is then funnelled into
a chamber or tank. The water so-collected, depending on
location of the tank, can be circulated into the home
using either an electrical water pump or gravitational
force.
In addition to covering gutters and drainage channels,
their periodic dredging of silt and plastic bags will
reduce the risks of street flooding. Debates with the
Amuwo-Odofin
local
government
authorities,
the
To have an effective
preparedness plan, there has to
be a major modification of our
personal and institutional
attitudes towards response to
disasters
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
51
Climate Change Unit, and with members of the newly-
constituted Local Emergency Management Committee,
supplemented by street
interviews were part of
this
study. By way of disaster risk reduction, they revolved
around the movement of markets away from highways,
arterial and other access roads, the enforcement of a ban
on street-trading, but also around
the
necessity of
creating
specific
posts
for
small-scale
commercial
activities, including cafeterias.
In summary, what is being proposed to the Amuwo-
Odofin
Local
Government
is
a
budgeted,
3-tier
framework, encapsulated in the Table below developed
from the
Public awareness and public education for
disaster
risk
reduction
2011
document
of
the
International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent
Societies:
1. Preventive initiatives for disaster risk reduction:
Public awareness, campaigns and public education;
formal school classroom lessons on environmental
conservation,
sanitation,
waste
management
and
storage of inflammables in the home. Also, how to
detect and report hazards and where to obtain weather
forecasts; what to do in an emergency, e.g. first aid,
call an ambulance, fire service and police, and how to
reach a hospital. Stockpiling of
relief
materials,
relevance of environmental governance procedures
such as impact assessments and audit is also necessary.
2. Reactive processes:
Development and synchronization of alerts and early
warnings to simultaneously and instantly reach the
designated network of the fire service, police, the
Naval Base, hospitals and ambulance services, Red
Cross, churches and mosques, volunteers, schools, the
Local Emergency Management Committee, National
Youth Service Corp, Climate Change Unit, the Lagos
State Emergency Management Authority, the Lagos
State
Environmental
Protection
Agency
and
the
National Emergency Management Agency. Added to
this is transportation of victims to pre-determined
places of refuge; medical care, blankets and warm
clothing, beds and food.
3. Post-disaster relief:
Counselling of displaced persons; stock-taking of
damage, including loss of lives and property, cost
implications, insurance claims; offsetting of medical
bills; getting the children to school; refurbishing of
damaged home and
return
of
refugees on
flood
recession.
52
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
World cities
population growth
data courtesy of NLÉ
Typical
Lagos
traffic jam, by
Aderemi Adegbite
World Cities population growth per hour
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
53
When Nasir El-Rufai travelled to Lagos for the
first
time
in
December 1979 he
found
it
underwhelming.
“I
was disappointed by what I saw in Lagos, quite
frankly. I did not get to see the Bar Beach and other nice
attractions; I did not visit Victoria Island and Ikoyi,
which were the highbrow residential neighbourhoods at
the time. I saw the not so good parts and thought, if this
is Lagos, then it is nothing impressive.”
El Rufai’s words from his memoirs as Minister of
Nigeria’s Federal Capital, Abuja - The Accidental Public
Servant - reveal the two-faced reality that is the city of
Lagos, a reality which has survived through the decades
till date. The reality being that Lagos, while alluding to
excellence
and
cosmopolitan
sophistication,
bears
nothing but a very thin veneer of gloss over a widely
distributed core layer of grime.
Fast forward
to 2010 and El-Rufai visits Governor
Babatunde Fashola to congratulate him “over the visible
improvements recorded in his administration of Lagos
State.”
True, there have been ‘visible improvements.’ However,
it is apparent that a lot of this improvement has been in
returning urban
infrastructure
in
the highbrow areas
El-Rufai missed on his first visit, and some middle-
income neighbourhoods like Surulere and Yaba to the
state they should have been maybe twenty years ago.
Even
at
that,
Ikoyi
and
Victoria
Island
are
two
‘highbrow’ areas still to be really free from the menace
of bad roads and flooding. In other parts of Lagos, yes
there are BRT vehicles plying dedicated lanes to lessen
the chaotic transportation situation; yes the light rail
system connecting Badagry to Lagos Mainland is well
underway and would hopefully soon be commissioned;
the Bar Beach El-Rufai failed to see in 1979 has now
given way to a whole new city being built from scratch
on the Atlantic ocean - the Eko Atlantic City - and
numerous
roads
and
drainage
systems
have
been
overhauled across most of Lagos. Still, the questions
persist: why do most neighbourhoods in Lagos still look
so poor and decrepit? Why does it seem so difficult for
the delivery of public goods to match the demand in
Lagos, especially with respect to urban planning and
service delivery? Three ready knee-jerk answers to this
are: corruption, greed and the exploding population. In
2010, Urban Spaces Innovation, a Lagos-based NGO
concerned with affordable and quality housing
for
Nigeria’s urban poor identified
“a housing deficit of
about 5 million
in Lagos, representing 31% of
the
estimated national housing deficit of 18 million.”
Typical government efforts
to
address
the shortage
result in 1,000 to 3,000 housing units at best being built
at a time in widely-dispersed locations, hardly making a
dent in actual demand. If the government can back
private investors in creating an ambitious project like the
Eko Atlantic City, designed to cater for 250,000 people
- the super-rich, to be specific - then it is of great
necessity
for
government
to
support
even
more
ambitious and forward-looking plans to create liveable,
sustainable communities for a larger population.
Corruption has proven a distraction from meaningful
problem-solving because usually, statements that place
corruption at the root of dysfunction in public service
delivery are more of self-fulfilling prophecies
than
anything else. Same for the population conundrum; as
much as the escalating population presents problems it
also provides numerous opportunities, if well harnessed.
The
residents
distrust
the
government based on sustained
fears
of
harassment,
displacement
and
possible
prosecution
Urban Planning and the Delivery of Public Goods and Services
By: Ayodele Arigbabu
Ayodele Arigbabu
studied Architecture at
the University of
Lagos, where he was at
different times the
Librarian and
President of the Pen
Circle, an association
of young writers. He is
currently Creative
Director at Design And
Dream Arts (DADA)
Ent. And a partner at
The Architects
Collaborative.
54
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
I wager that the real culprit is a lack of imagination; and
greed is a symptom of that lack.
In December 2012, Heinrich Böll Stiftung organized a
forum on
flood prevention methods
for
low-lying
communities
in Lagos. The workshop was held
in
partnership with the Departments of Architecture and
Urban & Regional Planning of the University of Lagos.
It
brought
together professionals, academics, social
workers, residents and other stakeholders with expertise
in
the
field.
After
three
days of
intensive
effort,
resultant design ideas and strategies were presented and
discussed. Two of these were subsequently selected to
be supported through a second phase of the initiative
that would involve community engagement. The aim
was to test the strength of the proposed ideas/strategies
with the communities that were meant to benefit from
them.
This process led to two groups organizing community
engagement meetings from March to April 2013. Each
was headed by Rosemary Omoayena Yadua , a lecturer
at the Department of Urban and Regional Planning of
the
University
of
Lagos,
and
Michael
Temidayo
Johnson, an architect. They worked with a sample of
about 30 residents living in Makoko, (a low-income
community)
and
community
representatives
from
Amuwo Odofin (a middle-income community) on the
challenges they faced with flooding, possible solutions
that could help mitigate those challenges and action
plans for implementing relevant strategies.
The Makoko study
revealed
that due
to
its unique
low-lying topography, the community tends to be a
receptacle
for
flood
water
from
surrounding
neighbourhoods
like Sabo-Yaba, Onike and Iwaya.
This is exacerbated by buildings erected wrongly on the
banks of the canal (which should collect flood water in
Makoko and environs). Quite a few buildings obstruct
and constrict the canal to a narrow gutter, making it
impossible
for
rainwater
run-off
to
be
speedily
redistributed.
Makoko is a low-income community that has grown on
the fringes of the Lagos lagoon for over a century. It is
instructive that the neighbouring Yaba community is
structured around a grid-iron
layout
inherited from
colonial
planning
efforts
and
has
benefited
from
What these failings have
achieved is to give middle-
income neighbourhoods that
had been developed with some
recourse to planning at
inception, a legacy of enduring
decay, which makes them largely
indistinguishable from more
impoverished neighbourhoods.”
Existing Canal in
upper Makoko, by
Rosemary Yadua
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
55
The government distrusts the residents, considering
them
to be
illegal occupants
–
at
least
those who
encroach on the canal’s right of way or who have built
out
into
the
lagoon
-
with
no
legal
titles
and
perpetrators of what is considered an urban blight. The
residents distrust the government based on sustained
fears
of
harassment,
displacement
and
possible
prosecution.
With this sort of tenuous relationship it is ironic that the
preferred
solution
adopted
at
the
community
engagement meetings requires the active participation,
support and collaboration of government and residents
of the community to enable implementation. As Yadua
states
in an
interview at
the end of
the meetings:
“Brainstorming together actually really helped, with
ideas
from
different
stakeholders.
We
had
the
architect’s view, the engineer’s view and all that. It was
a good thing that we came to them [the residents]
because if we had imposed our design on them, it is
obvious it probably would not have worked at all.”
The preferred idea is centred on a reclamation of the
canal right of way through demolition of contravening
structures where necessary, a re-introduction of the
appropriate setbacks / flood plains where applicable
and
the
introduction
of
urban
farming
and
non-
motorized travel on the setbacks of the canals, as well
as
the creation of economic activities
tied
to
the
initiative, to ensure the community gets full benefits.
extensive
infrastructure
upgrades
by
the
State
government in the past decade.
Though the name
Makoko brings to mind the houses on stilts (built from
the banks of the lagoon into the immediate shallow
depths of the water) that typify the region, the Makoko
community actually has a sizable population living on
land stretching inward from the banks of the lagoon.
This part of
the community suffers not
just
flash
flooding during the rains, but also flooding during high
tide and experiences groundwater seepage. Yadua’s
community engagement meeting centred on the area
called
‘Makoko-on-land.’ However,
there was also
representation
from
the
‘Makoko-on
water’
community. It is difficult to separate the two, especially
given
the added prominence which a government-
enforced demolition in July 2012 (of some stilt houses
on the lagoon) has now lent to the name Makoko,
regardless of whether it happened on land or water.
Makoko has barely survived that demolition, thanks
largely
to
timely advocacy and mediation with
the
government by concerned professionals, civil society
groups
and
other
stakeholders.
The
exercise
was
ostensibly carried out on build-outs
that
extended
beyond a line of high tension electricity pylons and at
least one life was lost in the process. The overarching
belief is that government seeks to relocate all
‘slum
dwellers’ in the area to make way for a high profile
waterfront real estate development, which would be
priced beyond the reach of current residents.
Urban farming concept
for Makoko canal by
Rosemary Yadua
56
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
According to the group that steered the deliberations,
“this was concluded to give a sustainable solution to the
problems of flooding and also ameliorate the poverty
that is inherent in the study area.”
The proposed introduction of urban farming on the
canal
setbacks
is
perhaps
the
most
significant
component of the initiative, given the advantages it
affords
for
environmental
sustainability,
economic
empowerment and the creation of a physical, living
barrier
to
future
encroachment.
It
is
even
more
noteworthy that there is no aspect of the proposal that
can
be
implemented
without
active,
support,
collaboration and direct leadership from the state.
Michael
Temidayo
Johnson’s
findings
at
Amuwo
Odofin are even more disturbing.
Located on the international route that connects Lagos
to Benin Republic, Amuwo Odofin is known for a
number of residential estates including FESTAC Town,
Satellite Town and Jakande Estate, which were built by
previous Federal and State governments. There are
some private estates in Amuwo Odofin as well, making
it a major residential area. Johnson focused on the
Jakande Estate (which lies on the boundary of the actual
Amuwo Odofin Local Government Area) and
the
FESTAC Extension neighbourhood for his community
engagement study. FESTAC Extension was developed
as an add-on to the FESTAC Town project, an area built
by the Federal Government to accommodate guests and
officials of the 2nd Festival of Arts & Culture, which
held in 1977. FESTAC Town was thus well planned
and built with adequate infrastructure, most of which,
though largely not maintained, continues to serve the
estate. FESTAC Extension, being an add-on to the
original FESTAC, was built with some thought for
basic infrastructure.
The
Jakande
Estate,
which
separates
FESTAC
Extension from FESTAC Town was built in the 1980s
by the government of former Lagos State Governor,
Lateef Jakande. Both FESTAC Extension and
the
Jakande Estate are nestled between the Apapa-Oshodi
Expressway and the Lagos-Badagry Expressway.
Factors responsible for the challenges residents of both
communities face concerning flooding were identified
by Johnson as: indiscriminate dumping of refuse and
littering, which is exacerbated by an inadequate refuse
disposal
system,
leading
to
blocked
drains.
Unauthorized building on flood plains and drainage
basins,
including
other
areas
not
meant
for
development;
the poor state of roads and drainage
infrastructure, as well as the lack of a maintenance
culture were also noted.
Evident in both communities is palpable confusion over
the appropriate Federal, State or Local government
agencies
that
should
be
responsible
for
the
administration and maintenance of
the estates. The
different tiers of government are cited as quick to claim
levies and
taxes and compete with other
tiers
for
jurisdiction, but slow to take charge and arrest the urban
decay afflicting the estates. This decades-long neglect
represents the extent to which the estates in Amuwo
Odofin surpass Makoko’s tale of woe.
Unlike
Makoko,
which
never
had
decent
urban
planning
nor
drainage
infrastructure
(beyond
the
incomplete canal system) from the onset, the Amuwo
Odofin estates were planned and built by government
with functional drainage
infrastructure at
inception.
Nevertheless, negligence has reduced the estates to a
deplorable state of deterioration that rivals some of the
worst parts of Makoko.
Johnson’s proposal had Sustainable Urban Drainage
Systems (SUDS) as a primary focus but he also notes
that:
“a
social/administrative
component
involving
constant communication and public engagement (was
necessary) to create an awareness for the system and
educate the public at large, as well as legal and political
frameworks that support and reward system application
and maintenance.”
In addition, “an infrastructural component that would
feature
technologies
such
as
rainwater
harvesting,
pervious surfaces and paving,
rainwater detention,
retention and
infiltration
as well as an alternative
waste/refuse management system” are necessary for his
planned system to work in the estates.
While Johnson’s observations have clearly defined the
need
for
citizen
engagement
and
participation
in
managing the environment, it is impossible for any of
the basic ideas he has proposed to yield results without
some adoption and direction
from government.
In
reality, the problems emerged in the first instance due
to
government
failings.
What
these
failings
have
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
57
achieved in the case of the Amuwo Odofin estates, is to
give
middle-income neighbourhoods
that
had been
developed with some recourse to planning at inception a
legacy of enduring decay, which makes them largely
indistinguishable
from
more
impoverished
neighbourhoods.
And the blame need not be placed with the people. Yes,
waste disposal is an issue and social norms present
challenges
to environmental management. However,
where opportunities are presented for communities to
pull together for the public good, progressive outcomes
have been had in the past. Since the early 90s and
probably earlier, neighbourhood associations in Lagos
have constituted themselves into forces to be reckoned
with regarding security provision for residents in the
face of blatant shortcomings by the police in doing so.
These associations remain in many communities, even
with improved state involvement on security. In many
cases,
communities
collaborate
with
the
state
in
achieving the desired objectives.
Another instance that is directly related to our concerns
with environmental management is the Makoko floating
school - initiated by the private sector as a design / social
intervention
for
the
benefit
of
Makoko
residents1.
Supported by civil society through research funding
Existing road above and
alternative road design
below for Jakande Estate
in Amuwo Odofin by
Michael Johnson
58
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
from Heinrich Boll Stiftung, it was made possible by
community leaders who lent civic support, and adopted
by
the residents for whom
it
was conceived. This
initiative (which served as a prototype scheme for
Kunle Adeyemi,
the architect whose urban design
practice
NLÈ
conceived
the
project)
was
not
government driven. Nevertheless, the extended version
of the project which should see its A-frame modules
being replicated in different configurations across the
lagoon
cannot
be
achieved
without
government
backing.
It is interesting to note that part of Adeyemi’s research
asserts
that
the
people of
‘Makoko-on-water’
had
already
achieved
remarkable
levels
of
physical
planning, density, socio-economic management and
civic
governance
without
state
intervention.
The
Makoko community were yet again able to demonstrate
their capacity for self-organization and collaboration
when during a
follow-up workshop organized by
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
in October 2013,
they had
representation
from
their
leaders
and
participated
actively
in
appraising
urban
renewal
proposals
presented to them by Urban Spaces Innovation and
Fabulous Urban2. Residents also took part in debating
funding proposals and other details of the plans. They
exhibited
sufficient
imagination
to
transform
their
community
into
an
economically
viable
and
sustainable,
modern
environment,
unique
in
its
aesthetic appeal and location.
That
staff
from
different
ministries
in
the
State
Government
attended
and
participated
at
these
meetings is encouraging, and shows government can be
engaged at the level of ideas. What is not certain is if
government can
take
the
leap required
to mediate
partnerships and deploy resources at the sort of scale at
which the Eko Atlantic City is being built, to deliver
public goods
in urban design and
infrastructure
to
low-income
and
middle-income
communities
like
Makoko and the estates at Amuwo Odofin.
It is ironic that in a developing economy like Lagos,
public perception holds that the government is set up to
service the interest of the corporate sector and the rich.
This
perception
is
further
complicated
by
strong
attempts by government
to assess
the considerable
un-banked
informal economy and
therefore capture
them within the tax bracket, meaning that there is some
appreciation of the capacity of citizens in the low-
income
bracket
to
contribute
significantly
to
the
economy3. Proper and continued
investment
in
the
infrastructure that would help unlock that capacity in
the first place is crucial. As proponents of economic
initiatives, the private sector is connected to the public
sector via citizenship, taxation, regulation, etc and has
the capacity to unlock value but must engage with the
public sector to ensure the delivery of public goods to
the society. The public sector in turn must be open to
this engagement; nay, the public sector must be willing
to drive the process. This sort of collaboration happens,
and
is
only sustained
through consistent
feedback
loops; a flux of well-intentioned collaboration between
the public sector, the private sector and the society that
benefits from this interaction, one that need not be
defined by hierarchies but rather by shared goals and
objectives.
END NOTES:
1
http://www.nleworks.com/case/makoko-floating-school/
2 For the Makoko-Iwaya Waterfront Regeneration Plan. On invitation of the Lagos State Ministry of Physical Planning and Urban
Development. A collaboration of Fabulous Urban, Geneva, Switzerland; Serac (Urban Spaces Innovation), Lagos, Nigeria; the Heinrich
Böll Foundation, Abuja and Lagos, Nigeria, and the local community.
3 “Lagos State Government uncovers 5.5 million tax evaders in informal sector.” http://www.vanguardngr.com/2013/05/lasg-uncovers-5-
5m-tax-evaders-in-informal-sector/
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
59
Q: Climate Change Adaptation
in
a
Megacity
cannot be the task of one Ministry alone but in
Lagos it seems it is mainly the MoE that is responding
to concerns. Tell us a little bit about what you are doing
in this area?
I
want
to
correct
the
impression
that
Lagos State
Ministry of Environment is the only ministry involved
with the task of tackling the adverse effects of climate
change. MDAs (Ministries, Departments and Agencies)
within
the
Lagos
State
government
are
working
collectively to tackle climate change in Lagos State. The
Ministry of Environment is just the arrowhead of the
work being done. If you look around Lagos, you will see
some mitigating measures in place like the BRT bus
programme under the Ministry of Transportation but
managed by Lagos State Metropolitan Area Transport
Authority (LAMATA). If you
look at
the on-going
Lagos – Badagry Expressway construction, you would
discover that there is a light rail component along the
project that is also being managed by LAMATA.
Q: How does the light rail component help in climate
change adaptation?
It’s a mass transit system that will help ferry a lot of
people. Rather than everybody bringing their cars to
emit carbon dioxide, it is actually a mitigating measure
to help reduce the carbon footprint in Lagos. If you
compare the rate of emission, the carbon footprint from
the light rail would be much less than that of the many
cars we use so we are actually mitigating against the
adverse impact of climate change.
Q: So what does
the Ministry of Environment do
specifically in the area of climate change adaptation?
The Ministry of Environment has two MDAs under it:
We have the office of Environmental Services, who
manage
the environment
to make
it
sustainable. So
issues relating to carbon emission, waste management,
climate change and environmental planning policy are
domiciled within the office of Environmental Services.
The office of Drainage Services deals on the other hand,
with issues relating to storm water management, flood
management and all issues relating to rivers and water
resources. With global warming we have rising sea
levels,
it
is
the responsibility of office of drainage
services to look at how to make the channels, the streams
the rivers that we have around sustainable. Don’t forget
that there is this other component of flooding from the
costal zones, where we have storm surges like what they
are having in the UK now. We also have the Lagos State
Ministry of Waterfront Infrastructure, they are actually
managing and trying to mitigate the Bar Beach erosion
and flooding.
Q: The research of our different partners revealed that a
fair and efficient land tenure system, including the fair
use of public spaces, is very important for effective
climate change adaptation. What is the current tenure
system in Lagos State? Is the government looking to
change it?
There is a Land use Act of 1978, which vests all the land
within any state in the hands of the state government. So
every portion of land here in Lagos belongs to the Lagos
State government. So if you want to use any piece of
land you must come for the title. Now if we are talking
about illegal occupation of open spaces in Lagos State.
These are different issues. People just come into Lagos
without having a place to work or a place to stay. They
target the open spaces especially the swampy areas and
The Green Revolution is on but is Silent - Hakeem Ogunbambi
Interview By Nicholas Ibekwe
Hakeem \Ogunbambi
is the permanent
secretary for the Lagos
State Ministry of
Environment in
Nigeria
60
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
the marshy lands and try to do illegal reclamation. What
we’ve been able to do with open spaces is to green them
- that is another effort of trying to combat the effect of
climate change. You will see the greening efforts all
over Lagos State, from the loops around the bridges and
the
interchanges. Some of
those areas you refer as
landed areas, are not actually landed areas; they are
illegally being reclaimed by squatters. If you
travel
along the Third Mainland Bridge before you get to the
University of Lagos, if you look to you right, you will
see places where illegal reclamation is taking place.
Illegal squatters use waste to reclaim this place. We
don’t refer to such areas as land. If you really want to
reclaim any land you have to use sand to fill properly in
order to improve the nature of the marshy land. What we
have there is illegal reclamation. As a matter of fact, it is
what we call pollution of the environment.
Q: Increasingly Lagos has become flood prone. One of
the contributing factors is the lack of a proper drainage
system. The old drainage system built for a Lagos with
only the fraction of today’s inhabitants needs to be
overhauled. Many drainage canals and gutters are out of
use since people have built on them – not only the poor
people with shanty houses but also
“official” estates
where people were allowed
to obstruct drainage by
erecting new buildings on the drainage canals/gutters.
One example
is
the
Makoko/Yabo where
the
old
drainage canal is blocked by Oyediran Estate. Is there a
policy
for
dealing
with
this
problem
and
what
specifically is your ministry doing in this area?
First of all you need
to understand
the underlining
principle of the methodology of flow of the storm water
channels and rivers in Lagos. All over the world there
are
just
two measures
to drive
flow of
rivers and
artificial channels. The two methods are gravitational
method and the pump method. About 90 per cent of the
world uses the gravitational method because it’s cheap
and easily managed. The remaining 10 per cent uses the
pump method. So in Lagos, the policy is to make the
water
flow
in
these
channels
through gravitational
method. In a place where
the gravitational method
doesn’t work, we try to keep people away from the area.
It is not that the pump method cannot be practiced here
but we do not have the energy or power supply to run the
pumps. So the policy is that with these areas to reduce
the damage to properties and danger to human beings,
we advice people to go to dry land. So when the rainy
season passes, you tell them to come back, it’s a strategy
that has been working. It is an adaptation measure that
actually works all the time. It is important that we know
Low-lying flood-
prone area in Lagos by
Aderemi Adegbite
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
61
which areas in Lagos are susceptible to flooding and for
these areas common sense dictates that we vacate the
area temporarily for the water to subside and that is
essentially what is being practiced all over the world.
Q: What about resettlement areas? Can you just tell
people to vacate their houses without providing shelter
where they can stay until the water subsides?
We have resettlement areas. There is one in Agbowa
already.
Q: What is the capacity of this shelter?
About 1000 people…
Q: And is that enough for a city as huge as Lagos?
Not all areas get flooded in Lagos. The case of July 10
2011, was different. There was rainfall for about 11
hours. This kind of rainfall happens only once in 80
years. And immediately after the rainfall, the entire
landscape changed from wet to dry. This is not the same
as what we are seeing
in England where areas are
flooded for close to two week and people could not get
back to their homes. But in Lagos, immediately the rain
stops everybody gets back to their homes. That is the
way we have been able to manage flood in the state.
Look at what happened
in 2012,
three quarters of
Nigeria was flooded. What happened to Lagos, it was
clean and dry despite the fact that we are located along
the
shoreline.
It
tells
you
that
our
storm
water
management strategy and policy is working. The state
government continues to deploy major resources to deal
with the problem because we recognise our nearness to
the cost makes us vulnerable to rising sea level rise and
climate change issues. That is why the state government
takes these matters very seriously.
Q: You’ve spoken of
the gravitational method
for
controlling flood waters, what other things are you doing
to control flooding?
Another strategy which
is
part of
the gravitational
method is the creation of retention ponds. We have these
ponds all over the state but increasingly they are being
In a situation where water will
not flow under the gravitational
method you keep people away
from the place.
Iwaya community
on the Lagoon by
Aderemi Adegbite
62
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
encroached upon. Look at the one near the National
Theatre, we call it the Oto Creek, if you look at it you
will discover that people keep trying to build structures
and use waste matter to fill up the creek. The attitude of
these people increases the chance of flooding because
they are essentially the making the ponds dysfunctional
so the water which has to go somewhere flows back and
floods nearby communities.
Q: What about shanties and estates built on water
channels? What is the state doing about them ?
As part of the policy, anything that obstructs flow is
removed.
Q: In some areas compensation has been a problem after
the removal of these sorts of infractions. For example is
some cases there is no compensation and these instances
can be found across all social segments in society. It’s
a delicate and sensitive issue – how can it be properly
handled?
There is this adage that says that when there is no law
there is no sin. Lagos State has laws so people cannot
just wake up and say: “I want to put this structure down
and nobody is going to stop me. The rules and laws are
there. Before you do anything, first of all carry out
investigations.
People
cannot
begin
to
say
that
government is demolishing their structure and is not
paying
any
compensation.
We
have
done
many
demolitions in Lagos and those who have development
permits and those who were given approval by physical
planning have been compensated appropriately. But I
can tell you that majority of developers don’t have
papers at all. They disregard all the rules and laws. So if
you hear people crying and saying government has
dispossessed them of their properties, it’s inaccurate, we
must respect the law. For instance the people in Makoko
are there illegally. Ask for their documents and ask
them how they came to be living in Makoko.
Low-Lying flood
prone settlement
with waste
management
challenges in
Lagos, by
Aderemi Adegbite
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
63
But many have been living there for generations….
There
is nothing
like generations. I have a map of
Makoko, which was taken in 1973, you won’t see any of
those squatters. All
the streams were flowing. The
Oyadiran stream used to be about 50 metres wide, if you
go there, the channel is now just about 5 metres. I can s
show you the image of the shoreline then. It has now
been extended by over 300 metres by all the illegal
squatters.
There
are
scientific
ways
of
actually
measuring the illegalities these people have committed.
Lagos state has the right to remove people when they
have
constituted
themselves
into
an
environmental
nuisance. Answer this question how do they dispose
their defecation? Straight into the Lagos lagoon. The
commonwealth belongs to everybody but only these few
people maybe five or 10 thousand people are trying to
pollute the Lagos lagoon. Lagos lagoon is a natural
resource that gives people lives. Water is life. If you take
a sample of fish from Lagos lagoon, people will tell you
about all sort of things embedded inside the fish, which
is not good for our health. People have even started
speculating that some cancers are caused by eating fish
taken out of the Lagos lagoon. The linkage is very clear.
Removing the people of Makoko will reduce the level of
pollution
within
the
fish.
You will
reduce
health
problems within Lagos. That is the truth. The problem is
that
people
have
never
linked
the
serious
health
problems to the pollution being generated. You know
the kind of waste that they bring in? They bring in
hazardous waste, medical waste and all sorts of things
and dump it straight into the lagoon. And you want the
government to keep quiet. It’s not right. If they want to
live on state structure
there are ways
they can be
regulated. People live on water abroad, but they manage
all their waste
–
both wastewater and solid waste
–
properly, they don’t dump it into the lagoon.
Q: Many new estates are springing up, especially along
the
Lekki-Epe
axis.
Surprisingly,
despite
the
commitment of
the
government
to
climate
change
adaptation, CO2 reduction etc, there is no provision to
introduce binding sustainable building principles, or
financial encouragement for the use of modern energy
efficiency technology. Why is that?
Lagos State has laws so people
cannot just wake up and say: “I
want to put this structure down
and nobody is going to stop me.
Makoko
fringe
units on stilts, by
Fabulous Urban
64
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Petrochemical
Industry in the
Lekki Free Zone
by Ajibola Oseni
What you are referring to is green buildings, green
infrastructures, etc. The first thing I would tell you about
making a building efficient in the greening aspect is your
energy and lighting system. People are beginning to use
energy-efficient bulbs inside their homes. Bulbs that will
last more cause a reduction in their carbon emission.
That is what they refer to as energy efficient bulbs.
That’s what we have entirely in the State secretariat
here. In order to do that you need to have what we call
conservation. If you go to Eko Hotel, for example, if you
walk around the corridor you will discover that the light
will never come on unless you walk close to the bulb.
That is what government is doing. Telling people to as
much as possible reduce energy consumption. These
new estates you are talking about in Lagos, some of
them are even using solar panels
to generate
their
electricity on their own. Lagos state too is encouraging
everybody to go green. There is an awareness campaign.
There is the operation green Lagos to make people
aware of the benefits. If you look at the streetlights you
discover that we are trying to use solar for some of them.
Also Lagos is encouraging industries to use gas. Look at
where we are coming from
in Nigeria. How many
Nigerians care about going green? How many Nigerians
have
heard
about
green
infrastructures
and
green
buildings except people
living
in Lagos? So
it’s
a
gradual process and it’s going to catch on. And I can bet
you in five years you will begin to see the difference
emerging within Lagos state. The green revolution is on
but it’s silent.
Q: In the Lagos Free Trade Zone,residential areas and
those targeting (eco) tourism are sitting side by side
with heavy industrial areas, especially petrochemical
industries. This is very similar to what happened in
Apapa with the influx of tank farms into residential and
office areas. The installation of petrochemical industry
along beautiful beaches, which offer high potential for
eco-tourism, is worrisome. Why has government not
learned its lesson from Apapa?
What’s the difference between a planned area and a
slum? We have what we call nature’s slums and the
artificial slums. The natural slum is like a cluster of
tenements, which are not properly planned. They will
degenerate because you have not actually configured
things
properly. But
in
a planned area, you plan
everything but you can have negative interventions. If
you look at Apapa, the negative intervention actually
came from the Federal Government because the port is
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
65
Map of Lekki Free
Zone courtesy of
Lagos State
Government
located there and it was not properly controlled. The
federal government during the military era caused the
degeneration of Apapa. Lekki Free Trade Zone is not the
creation of the Federal Government, neither is it going
to be managed by the Federal Government. It is going to
be managed by the Lagos State government. We build
cities because we want the cities to be comfortable, to be
profitable and to be safe. These are basically the three
reasons why we develop cities. And the Lekki Free
Trade Zone is going to be a city. If you really want all
these three things to be there we must put the necessary
controls. That is why agencies of government called
Physical Planning, Lagos Building Control and Ministry
of the Environment are involved. The physical planning
people will ensure all physical laws are applied properly,
that you abide by building regulations. The Ministry of
Environment has it’s own role to play by ensuring that
structures that fall within the confines of the Free Trade
Zone
have
a
proper
EIA
(Environmental
Impact
Assessment)
conducted.
Also,
the
impact
will
be
monitored during construction.
The lesson learnt from Apapa is that first of all, we must
stick to the plan rather than keep adjusting it . If you are
going
to modify
the plan you must come out with
mitigating measures to justify modifying the plans. They
built Apapa port first with a limited space, they have
now put in an additional port called Tin can Island Port
and they never bothered to change the scope of all the
infrastructure there –the thickness of the road, the width
of the road, the need to increase the number of roads
servicing the port area etc. They just put in additional
load
-
the
Tin
Can
Island
port
–
without giving
consideration
to
the
negative
impact
it’s
going
to
generate all over Lagos. That is why you have the Apapa
– Oshodi Expressway being spoilt all the time because
of the increase in the number of trailers. And you have
the increase in the number of people servicing the port.
These people must have a place to sleep. There was no
corresponding increase in the number of housing built.
These are the issues when we talk about Environmental
Impact Assessment. Before you actually come up with
the plan, at the formative stage, you have projected into
the future so that by the time you begin the development
and the time you finish the development, you already
know what to expect and make room for it.
For Lekki Free Trade Zone, the state government has
plans to dualize the road leading to the Free trade Zone
already. It’s just that development in the free trade zone
hasn’t kicked off. Also there is the Fourth Mainland
Bridge that would take people across to Ikorodu to
wherever they want to go. Also don’t forget that the
Lekki- Epe Expressway is there too. There are plans in
the future to upgrade all the roads in Epe to link Ogun
State. These are the kind of plans that will make the
Lekki
Free
Trade
Zone
a
functional
city
not
a
dysfunctional city like Apapa.
66
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Superstition, cautious optimism, overwhelming rage
and complete distrust,
these
are
the
range of
emotions elicited from residents of Lagos state in an
anonymous online survey on
the Eko Atlantic City
project.
One respondent, said “brilliant ideas, but we have to be
careful to fully implement the concepts in this part of the
world
–professionalism must be the key priority not
POLITICS.”
Another was more incredulous: “Not so good idea: I'm
not sure I'm excited about pushing the Atlantic ocean
back to build on such an expanse. If the ocean vex [gets
angry]
nko?
I
guess
that'll
have
been
taken
into
account.”
From village-dwelling market women to well-educated
elites in Nigeria and abroad, most express concern over
the
ability
(or
the
lack
thereof)
of
the
current
government to operate and maintain such a significant
capital project or handle disasters that can potentially
occur as a consequence. The reactions are so strong even
among those who may be considered experts on the
environment and sustainability and that in response to an
invite to discuss creating sustainable design strategies,
one invitee said,
is it in the same country where
response to civil and everyday disaster is zero (that) we
want to live in the ocean?" "A o ni r’ija omi o!,( May we
not see the rage of the waters!),
The Eko Atlantic City is a massive, land reclamation
project on
the
coastline of Victoria
Island,
Lagos,
purportedly initiated to mitigate flooding and eradicate
the effects of erosion on the adjoining Bar Beach. By
February 2013, five million square metres of land had
been reclaimed.
Victoria Island is Lagos’ commercial nerve centre and
consistent, severe flooding over the last decade has had
significant negative
impacts on
the city’s economy.
Endemic tropical storms cause Atlantic Ocean’s water
level to rise, eroding the beach and flooding poorly-
drained road networks. Terrible traffic jams occur, with
workers either unable to get to work or to return home at
the
end
of
a
working day. Consequently,
several
businesses have moved their headquarters out of some
formerly key commercial streets such as Akin Adesola
Street.
A o ni r’ija omi o!,( May we not
see the rage of the waters!)- A
Yoruba prayer
Sustainable Design Strategies for Eko Atlantic City
By Bukky Oyedeji
Bukky Oyedeji, AIA,
NCARB, LEED AP
is the MD/CEO of
Zakiki Digital and
coordinator of the
Code Green Team
Coastal erosion at
Goshen Estate, by
Aderemi Adegbite
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
67
In response to this, foreign experts suggested to the
Lagos State Government that a levee – a sort of high
wall – be built to reduce erosion and flooding. This was
a
cost
intensive project
(about $9 billion) and
the
government did not have the funds to support it at the
time, (2003). However, while reviewing a 1905 map of
Lagos, it was discovered that the city’s coastline was
once about 2 km away
from
its
current
location,
suggesting that at least a kilometre of the beach has been
eroded over one hundred years. South EnergyX Ltd, a
private business entity then made an arrangement with
the government to finance and execute construction of
the needed wall, and then reclaim the lost land, with the
sole intent of selling it at a profit. This meant the Eko
Atlantic City project became live, albeit surreptitiously,
in February 2008.
Since inception, the city, which aims to accommodate a
quarter of a million people, has been marketed as a
cutting
edge,
high-end
sustainable
development.
According to the developers “ the city’s planners have
committed to minimizing Eko Atlantic’s carbon footprint
with the use of environmentally-efficient construction
methods and locally sourced materials where available
and appropriate.”
Also
promised
are
extensive
public
roadway
transportation, in conjunction with intra-land waterways
and heliports. These cursory statements, along with the
obvious reclamation of eroded land, consists all of the
sustainable
design
references
listed
in
the
city’s
marketing brochure. The document is inundated with
un-cited claims and statements that promise enormous
commercial gains, promising
foreign
investors
and
buyers
the opportunity
to
‘harvest
the potential of
Africa’ – a phrase that brings to mind the 19th century
western scramble for the continent. There is no definite
commitment to the implementation of sustainable design
strategies
that can also help resolve ecological and
socio-cultural challenges
(such as air pollution and
housing for low-income earners) which are prevalent in
Lagos.
Going further, a personal review of the city’s regulations
for specific plots of land in its downtown area did not
reveal any strong focus on green design issues. The
guidelines
provided
were
generic.
There
were
requirements for greenery in each lot but issues related
to
site
permeability,
storm-water
quantity
control,
construction activity pollution prevention, air, noise and
light pollution reduction were not addressed.
Also, when further challenged on
the sparseness of
clearly-defined sustainable design measures,
in May
2013
representatives
of
the
city’s
backers
stated
Superstition, cautious
optimism, overwhelming rage
and complete distrust, these
are the range of emotions
elicited from residents of
Lagos state in an anonymous
online survey on the Eko
Atlantic City project.
Aerial view of
Eko Atlantic City
Sand filling
reclamation
activity, courtesy
of Reinvent Media
68
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
unequivocally that such design measures are at best
tangential to their ultimate goal of profitability. This
unfortunate response to a very pertinent and global issue
confirmed the need to intervene by re-envisioning Eko
Atlantic City in a more sustainable fashion. One might
argue that the very existence of the city in itself is
unsustainable, but the unchanging fact is that at least
50% of the area intended for reclamation has already
been sand-filled, roads have been built, drainage lines
buried and some
lots
have been bought. The Eko
Atlantic City seems here to stay therefore, and in the
words of Rastamouse
(a
character on a children’s
program by
the
British
Broadcasting Corporation),
perhaps it is better to focus on
‘making a bad thing
good’…or a little less bad.
Consequently, in July 2013 the Code Green Campaign
was
initiated,
due
to
the strong
reaction perceived
amongst construction industry professionals surveyed
for their views regarding the city. The aim is to develop
sustainable guidelines for the Eko Atlantic City in the
hope that these can be adopted for future construction
projects.
Bearing
in
mind
the
City’s
proponents’
unapologetic focus on financial gains, the Code Green
group
decided
to
approach
the
initiative
from
an
investor’s
perspective.
It
determined
that
true
sustainability in an emerging economy such as that of
Lagos must have a strong economic component, along
with
ecological
and
socio-cultural
aspects.
Typical
challenges
that
investors may face during a project
delivery process
–from
land acquisition
to building
occupancy– were identified and then addressed from a
sustainability point of view. This means ecological
concerns and socio-cultural issues were noted, while
attempting to solve mostly economic and profitability
challenges.
Sustainable Construction
The first major challenge identified was funding costs.
Most Nigerian banks provide construction
loans at
interest rates of between 18% - 30% per annum. Typical
high-rise construction projects often take at least two
years to develop, implying that at minimum, a typical
investor would have accrued an additional 36%
in
interest
during
the
project
delivery
process.
The
challenge therefore, was to investigate faster, greener
ways to construct high-rise buildings so that loan interest
accruement and construction activity pollution decreases
while
building
envelope,
energy
and
construction
efficiency increases.
One of the ways identified was the use of prefabricated
building
systems.
Existing
prefabricated
building
systems are proven to significantly reduce construction
time, and have green design components that could be
adapted to meet local climatic and energy needs. An
example is the China-based Broad Sustainable Building
system where whole
sections
of
a
skyscraper
are
manufactured
in
a
factory,
thereby
reducing
construction costs and time, as well as construction
activity pollution. Furthermore, it has a high thermal
efficiency which helps reduce cooling costs and can
withstand magnitude 9 earthquakes and thunderstorms.
It also helps keep the air quality within its buildings
pure.
Several skyscrapers have been built using this system,
one of which is a 30-story hotel constructed in 15 days
in Hunan Province, China. To sustainably implement
such
a
system
in
Eko
Atlantic
City
however,
a
manufacturing facility for it may have to be set up in
Lagos or
in
the Eko Atlantic city
itself,
and
local
construction workers will need to be trained. This will
provide additional jobs, and increase the quality and
level of skills in the construction industry. Also, the
savings generated from using the system compared to
traditional construction methods may offset the initial
cost of adapting the technology to Lagos.
There is no definite
commitment to the
implementation of sustainable
design strategies that can also
help resolve ecological and
socio-cultural challenges
(such as air pollution and
housing for low-income
earners) which are prevalent
in Lagos.
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
69
Sustainable Cooling, Heating and Power Generation
The city requires every ground floor in the downtown
area to be mercantile, in order to create a high-end,
pedestrian shopping promenade. The
lot
regulation
stated that the ground floor’s front facade must be about
5 meters high and glazed. This will result in excessive
solar heat gain within these mercantile spaces, making
them hot and difficult to keep cool. Of course, green
design building techniques –such as the use of exterior
building
shading
systems
(e.g.
awnings),
natural
ventilation, vegetation, and building orientation –can be
incorporated in skyscraper designs so that heat gain is
minimized. However, artificial cooling will still be
required, especially during the hot and dry harmattan
season. This generated a discussion amongst Code
Green Campaign members, regarding the availability of
sustainable
cooling
systems
that
could
potentially
harvest solar heat gain or waste heat and re-use it for
other heating needs
(such as hot water) within a
building structure.
The
idea of adapting poly-generators
–
an engine
system that generates electricity and useful heat and
cooling sequentially or simultaneously for use within a
building facility or district – seemed most feasible. This
is because they are tested, are easily deployed and are
not a significant risk for profit-minded investors.
Known as Combined Cooling, Heat and Power Systems
(CCHP), poly-generators produce electricity, heating
and cooling from either the combustion of fuel or from
a solar heat collector, or both. Fuel powered CCHPs
burn either natural gas or fossil fuel and have a fuel
efficiency of about 80%. Most power-only generators
have a fuel efficiency that is below 50%.
The preference, of course, would be to power, heat and
cool the whole city with a project-wide, solar heat-based
CCHP, since that energy source is renewable. However,
this may not be feasible as the energy generated will
have to travel great distances to reach all skyscrapers.
Instead, the electricity needs of the city alone (including
streetlights,
parks,
etc)
can
be
provided
this
way
(distance is no barrier here) and the resultant cooling and
heating
energy
used
in
adjacent
buildings.
Other
skyscrapers can have their cooling and heating energy
provided by individual solar-based CCHP, assuming
that the city, through good governance, can provide and
maintain power supply to its inhabitants. Should city-
wide electricity generation fail, each building or street
may have a backup dual source CCHP in lieu of the
ubiquitous, inefficient, noisy, and air-polluting power-
only generators. A dual source CCHP can generate
electricity,
as
well as provide cooling and heating
energy, using either fossil fuel or stored solar power. It
can also provide just cooling and heating energy from
stored solar power when/if electricity generation is not
needed. This approach
to power generation can be
mandated or incentivized, by providing tax breaks to
compliant building owners.
Opting for adapted CCHPs at the Eko Atlantic City has
several advantages. It reduces the environmental impact
Sustainable
Building Design by
Code Green Team
70
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
of power generation by reducing carbon emissions and
air pollution, while re-capturing much of the waste heat
energy
that
has
contributed
to
unusually
high
temperatures experienced in Lagos in recent times. It
helps cool the spaces within buildings efficiently and its
energy source versatility can further reduce reliance on
fossil fuel energy. It initiates another opportunity for job
creation, by equipping local technicians with the skills
to install, operate and maintain these systems, while
providing
another
exemplary
alternative
to
power
generation for the rest of Lagos. Moreover, CCHPs can
easily be adopted by existing buildings and can be used
for different applications, including industrial ones.
Sustainable Building Use Optimizations
The
third
investor-driven perspective explored was
maximization of
leasable space. The
lot regulations
reviewed indicated that each skyscraper must step back
as it goes higher, in order to minimize shadows cast over
other buildings. What this means for investors though, is
that as the building goes higher, there is less square
footage to monetize. The task therefore, was to find
ways in which the ‘lost space’ could be utilized and even
monetized. One idea that gained traction was to move all
‘sociable’ communal spaces (lobbies, staff-break rooms,
cafeterias, non-private meeting rooms, or restaurants) to
the perimeter of the building in balconies and porches
that overhang the lower floors.
These balconies can be vegetated, providing shade and
reducing solar heat gain, purifying the air and providing
additional opportunities for natural ventilation in other
spaces. They can also be expressed as a form of vertical
urban
farming,
where
consumable
vegetables
are
planted. Since these gardens will be cantilevered spaces,
technically, the exterior walls of that floor will begin
where
the
lot
regulation
requires,
providing
more
money-generating spaces within the floor area. If every
skyscraper
in Eko Atlantic City were
to adopt
this
strategy
and
become a vertical
urban farm, then a
significant
chunk
of
food
security
issues
and
urban
poor challenges in
neighbouring low-
income areas may
be addressed.
Sustainable
Waste
Management
Asides the cost of
constructing
a
building
and
leasing it out, the
other
most
significant
cost
for
owners
is
that
of
operating and maintaining it. While power, heating and
cooling costs have been addressed by the use of passive
solar design strategies as well as sustainable cooling
systems,
waste
management
costs
tend
to
be
considerable over the life span of a building too. Waste
disposal has been a major challenge in the city of Lagos
for decades and as such, Eko Atlantic City has an
excellent opportunity to display how it can be managed
cost effectively.
Topside view of
sustainable building
for Eko Atlantic City
courtesy of Code
Green Team
Parking within the city should
attract a high fee, in order to
encourage use of the city’s
public transportation system.
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
71
Definitely, each building user – owner or tenant –should
be required to separate their waste, with separate bin
receptacles and/or chutes should be provided. Non-
compliant residents could be fined or deprived access to
some of the city’s communal privileges in order to
ensure complete compliance over
time. In addition,
kitchen sinks should be equipped with garbage disposal
grinders that crush food waste and have them collected
at locations where it can be processed into bio-mass fuel
and/or manure via compost heaps/bins. The manure can
be used for the building’s lawns and gardens – which of
course, ought to be planted with indigenous grass and
consumable
local vegetables. The gardens could be
rented out to low-income earners who can, through this
form of urban farming, generate additional income from
the sale of produce. Care must be taken though, to
ensure the water quality of the surrounding ocean is not
compromised by the planting activities.
Where food waste is converted to biomass fuel, it can be
used to power the building’s Combined Cooling Heating
and Power poly-generator, so that the building’s waste
is also its energy source. This will further reduce air
pollution, carbon emissions and reliance on fossil fuel
energy. Other waste such as paper, metals and glass can
be contracted for a minimal fee to local movers who will
transport and sell these to recyclers. In a development as
large as
the Eko Atlantic City,
this recycling-based
waste collection process can generate enormous
job
opportunities, contributing significantly
to
the
local
economy.
Sustainable Transit Systems
There is general concern for the impact of the city on
traffic
conditions, especially
in
Victoria
Island and
Ikoyi. The city’s marketing brochure currently states
that
waterway
transportation
will
be
provided
in
addition to public roadway transport. This waterway
transportation system should incorporate existing boat
and ferry stations across Lagos such as Ikorodu, Apapa,
Oworo, Unilag Lagoon Front, CMS and Makoko. In
addition, all public transportation vehicles – air, water or
land – could run on alternative energy sources such as
electricity or natural gas. Keke 2.0
–
a re-designed,
low-emission, clean energy and updated version of the
ubiquitous Keke Marwa commercial tricycle on Lagos’
streets – can be used in the city’s transportation system.
Parking within the city should attract a high fee, in order
to encourage use of
the city’s public
transportation
system. Aside from minimizing air pollution and carbon
emissions in the city, this will also reduce the cost of
running
the public
transportation system, making
it
accessible to low income earners.
The marketing brochure also states that heliport services
will be made available from the city to the Murtala
Mohammed
International airport. This
idea can be
successful environmentally if multiple passengers are
transported each time. In the absence of a known disaster
management plan for the city, it may be necessary for
some buildings to also have helipads in order to aid air
evacuation,
should
certain
types
of
disasters
(e.g.
flooding) occur.
The Way Forward
This vision for a truly sustainable Eko Atlantic City is a
huge but implementable one. Over the last decade, green
design
measures
and
products
have
undergone
significant testing and development and are no longer a
‘grey area’ when it comes to cost efficiency and validity.
If
the
economically
supportive
measures discussed
above become mandatory and are implemented, then
Eko Atlantic City may be well on its way to being the
most sustainable city in the Sub-Saharan Africa region –
and that, we are sure, is a tag line its developers would
like to take to the bank.
These balconies can be
vegetated, providing shade and
reducing solar heat gain,
purifying the air and
providing additional
opportunities for natural
ventilation in other spaces.
72
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
73
Impression of
Eko Atlantic
City Boulevard
by Code Green
Team
Impression of
Eko Atlantic
City Marina by
Code Green
Team
74
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
Q : You have been working in Asian countries
affected by coastal erosion and permanent
flood threats. What are your most common findings
about this problem?
Coastal erosion is a natural phenomenon. It is the desire
for economic development in some areas that causes
humans’ difficulty in coming to terms with it. Most
industrial/commercial development has historically
been driven in certain places where access to the sea for
shipping has been easy; rapid sea level rises render
these places the most vulnerable. Building coastal
defences is expensive and only works short-term, if at
all; even in the UK we have instances of simply
abandoning strips of coastline because defence is
impractical. The idea that we can conquer nature is
foolish and futile; but if these locations are so
important to business, then business (rather than
government) should shoulder the initial and long-term
costs of being in that location.
Places such as Aceh [Indonesia] are particularly at risk
from flooding by tsunamis because of their location,
height above sea-level, frequent seismic activity and
poverty. Poor infrastructure design, build quality,
sewage management systems, electricity distribution
and high population density increase the impact of
events and make recovery slower and more difficult.
Many such areas lack the indigenous capacity and
relative wealth to recover rapidly from catastrophic
events and are often at a distance from the
administrative/political centres of their nation.
Q : You have also done some research on disaster
preparedness and response regarding these threats,
for instance in post-tsunami Indonesia. What are the
best solutions?
For catastrophic events (tsunami & storm surge), the
problem can be split into two primary components;
minimising the death toll and infrastructure impacts.
Early warning systems are by far the cheapest and most-
effective
means
of
minimising
the
humanitarian
impacts; if people have time to escape or to take refuge,
then
the
death
toll
is
greatly
reduced. Damage
to
buildings and services (power, water, drainage, and
communications) is inevitable but can be minimised by
good design, putting as much as possible underground.
The exception being sewerage & drains; these will be
flooded and flushed anyway and scattered sewage is a
primary
health
risk
after
catastrophic
flooding.
Contamination
of
freshwater
supplies
(wells
&
boreholes) is one of the biggest concerns; water can be
brought in from outside but it is heavy to transport.
Possible solutions include forms of water storage, food
storage and access to some heavy machinery for moving
debris. Access to energy supplies is an additional need
soon after the initial event.
The Idea That we can Conquer Nature is Foolish - Alan Owen
Interview By Ruona Agbroko-Meyer
Dr Alan Owen is a
mechanical engineer
specializing in Marine
Energy and the
application of forces
by wave and tidal
dynamics. He is a
practical engineer who
has worked at sea,
built and deployed
large marine devices,
worked in remote
locations and in post-
disaster/post conflict
societies. Dr Owen is
the Director of the
Centre for
Understanding
Sustainable Practice
(CUSP) at the Robert
Gordon University in
Aberdeen, UK. More
information can be
found at
www.rgu.ac.uk/cusp
The most important
consideration is: should we be
building on this land at all?
Satellite Map of Kuramo waters in 2013 courtesy
Google Maps
Satellite Map of Kuramo waters in 2000 courtesy
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
75
The idea that we can conquer
nature is foolish and futile
Flooding of low-lying land by heavy rainfall and
sea-level changes is a more long-term event, often
resulting in crop failure, reduced access to potable
water supplies, increased disease risk and economic
failure. These areas are more difficult to manage as
there is often nowhere to pump flood water to, often
high levels of poverty and subsistence lifestyles, and
less resilient to loss of resources.
Q : What are the experiences of the people affected
in these Asian states?
The international community will usually take some
time
to respond and
the response can be variable
according
to
politics
between
the
international
community and the affected area/nation. There is also
the additional issue of financial aid coming from a
Western, Educated, Industrialised, Rich, Democratic
(WEIRD) perspective and with strings attached. In the
first
24-48 hours of any major, sudden event,
the
community
is
isolated and can only
fall
back on
Damaged
retention wall at
Goshen Estate, by
Adeyinka
Akingbade
Massive land
reclamation for
Eko Atlantic City
by Aderemi
Adegbite
76
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
immediately
available
resources,
which
are
often
minimal. Once the international aid communities have
fully
engaged,
the
response
is
usually productive,
though the receiving nation may find that it has been
given support which is inappropriate for the needs of
the
people. The biggest
long-term
risk
is
one of
dependency by the receiving community/nation on the
donor nations/organisations. Much of the post-disaster
economic activity is created by the relief project itself.
The recovery
time
is
long; Aceh
is
still
not fully
recovered from the 2004 tsunami.
Q : Over 40% of Lagos State in Nigeria is covered
by water and wetlands, while an additional 12% is
subjected to seasonal flooding. Please feel free to
describe in more detail any sort of measures used
elsewhere that Lagos can avail itself of regarding
disaster preparedness?
The most important consideration is:
“should we be
building on this land at all?” It is long term, cheaper and
safer to build away from flood plains, wetlands and
areas of coastal erosion. Environmentally, wetlands are
very important ecosystems and should be left alone
anyway. If development already exists then it should, if
possible, be moved. Simply building coastal protection
systems is expensive, unsustainable and often creates
the same magnitude of difficulty further down the coast.
Q
:
In May 2013,
the Lagos state government
announced it is seeking N 27 billion (about £102
million) to protect the shoreline over the next 3 years
from frequent ocean surges. What would you advise
a fast-growing coastal Megacity like Lagos to do to
cope with these threats?
If sea-level continues to rise (which is almost certain)
then the best solution is to find somewhere else to build.
Sea defences will only become a constant money-sink
and result in damage further along the coastline. Lagos
should not expand at the expense of other communities.
Q
:
Lagos’
government admits
that
“a
heavy
concentration of GDP generating
industries and
infrastructure near the coast further adds to the
state’s vulnerability.” Additionally, there are plans
to reclaim land and build along the Lagos coastline.
Generally, in what ways do you think government
and developers can protect their investments and
ensure steady economic growth despite the threats
of surges from the Atlantic Ocean?
Simply building coastal
protection systems is
expensive, unsustainable and
often creates the same
magnitude of difficulty further
down the coast.
Recently
erected groyne
at Elegushi
beach, by
Ajibola Oseni
Heinrich Böll Stiftung
77
Every square meter of hard surface reduces the area
available for absorption of water and creates increased
flood risk. If the water cannot be absorbed, it must flow
and will flow
to
the next available space. Not all
investments can be protected, some are just wrong.
Again,
the
idea
that
we
can
conquer
nature
(at
government expense) is futile. If the developers are so
certain,
let
them
pay
for
the
installation
and
maintenance
of
coastal
protection
measures.
True
economic growth needs to take account of sustainability
in the long term and finding a better location may be the
best decision.
Not all investments can be protected……
Beach House
at
Alpha
Beach by
Tunde
Akingbade
Goshen
Estate
perimeter
wall and
break-water
by Aderemi
Adegbite
Make-shift
Dwellings at
Kuramo
Waters by
Mbeke Efanga
Sand bar holding back the
Atlantic Ocean at Kuramo
Waters in 2013, courtesy
Monika Umunna
Fostering democracy and upholding human rights, taking action to prevent the destruction of the global
ecosystem, advancing equality between women and men, securing peace through conflict prevention in
crisis zones, and defending the freedom of individuals against excessive state and economic power –
these are the objectives that drive the ideas and actions of the Heinrich Böll Foundation. We maintain
close ties to the German Green Party (Alliance 90/The Greens) and as a think tank for green visions and
projects, we are part of an international network encompassing well over 100 partner projects in
approximately 60 countries. The Heinrich Böll Foundation works independently and nurtures a spirit of
intellectual openness.
The Megacity Lagos Programme is part of the Nigeria & West Africa Office of the Heinrich Böll
Foundation (hbs). It was in Lagos that the Foundation started its work in Nigeria in 1995. With its
headquarters now in Abuja and a liaison office in Lagos, hbs works with civil society and government
partners, policy shapers and gender activists
– to name only a few of the groups with whom the
foundation engages to inspire public debate on the development options before Nigeria. To quote its
patron, the German civil rights activist and author Heinrich Böll,
“Meddling is the only way to stay
relevant”.
Published by Heinrich Böll Stiftung Nigeria 2014
Opinions expressed in articles are those of their authors, and not hbs
This work is licensed under the conditions of a Creative Commons license:
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/. You can download an electronic version online. You
are free to copy, distribute and transmit the work under the following conditions: Attribution – you
must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in any way that
suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work), Noncommercial – you may not use this work
for commercial purposes, No Derivative Works – you may not alter, transform, or build upon this work.
Designed & Produced by
Reinvent Media Ltd
4 Bishop Crowther Street, Lagos
Tel: +234 705 858 7575
+234 802 367 6000
Email: info@reinventmedialtd.com
Web:www.reinventmedialtd.com
Cover Design by
Uche Chibututu ©2014
In Abuja:
93, Obafemi Awolowo Way,
Opposite Jabi Motor Park
Jabi District, Abuja.
Tel: + 234 1 761 2353
email: info@ng.boell.org
In Lagos:
City Hall (4th floor),
Catholic Mission Street,
Lagos Island, Lagos
Tel: +234 805 801 2226
email:monika.umunna@ng.boell.org
Heinrich Böll Foundation
www.ng.boell.org